Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · the cavalryman who knows 'some one had blunder'd' and rides on regardless

the soldier

in The Charge of the Light Brigade by Alfred, Lord Tennyson

The soldier shows up in the poem's second stanza as a stand-in for the six hundred cavalrymen who charged into the Valley of Death. He is marked by a single, crushing realization — that someone had blundered — and by his choice, or really his obligation, to keep riding forward. He doesn’t protest, question, or turn back. His importance lies in the space between what he knows and what he does: he realizes the order is wrong yet completely puts aside his own judgment in favor of following orders. In this way, he embodies the poem's themes of soldierly obedience, self-sacrifice, and the heavy toll of blind duty.

About this character

Role
the cavalryman who knows 'some one had blunder'd' and rides on regardless
Form
Short story
Author
Alfred, Lord Tennyson
First published
1854

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is the soldier?

The soldier in this poem represents an unnamed cavalryman from the Light Brigade. He isn't identified as an officer or a leader; instead, he embodies every ordinary rider in the charge. His key trait is his awareness, since the poem says "the soldier knew" that someone had blundered, which positions him as a figure of tragic understanding rather than ignorance.

02·Arc & motivation

What is the soldier's arc and motivation?

The soldier doesn't have a traditional character arc; the poem captures a single, pivotal moment of choice. His motivation stems from duty, encapsulated in the famous line "Their's not to reason why." His actions are not driven by blind ignorance but by a military code of obedience that completely overrides personal judgment.

03·Key moments

What are the soldier's key moments?

In Stanza 2, the soldier's awareness contrasts sharply with the command "Forward, the Light Brigade!" The rhetorical question "Was there a man dismay'd?" is answered by acknowledging that the soldier did recognize the blunder — yet he still rides on. This moment serves as the poem's moral and emotional pivot: knowing of the impending disaster does not lead to hesitation.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are the soldier's most important relationships?

The soldier's only relationship highlighted in the text is his affiliation with the Light Brigade. His individual awareness — the understanding of the blunder — quickly merges into the collective "Their's," shifting from the singular soldier to the plural six hundred. This grammatical transition illustrates the very suppression of individual will that the poem both celebrates and mourns.

05·Connected characters

How is the soldier connected to the other characters?

the Light Brigade

The soldier is one of the six hundred who make up the Light Brigade; his individual knowledge of the blunder is absorbed into the collective charge, and his fate is bound entirely to theirs.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about the soldier

Does the soldier try to stop the charge when he realises someone has blundered?

No, the poem indicates that while the soldier knew someone had blundered, it was "Their's not to make reply" and "Their's not to reason why," so he rides on without complaint or delay.

Is the soldier a specific, named person?

No. The poem depicts him as a symbol, an unnamed figure representing all six hundred cavalrymen of the Light Brigade.

What does 'their's but to do and die' tell us about the soldier's role?

It states that the soldier's only responsibility is to act and, if needed, to die — without questioning or responding. His personal will is completely subordinate to the command he has received.

Does the soldier show fear?

The poem poses the question, "Was there a man dismay'd?" suggesting that the answer is no. The soldier continues to advance, fully aware that the charge is a mistake.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Obedience vs. moral agency

    In what ways does the soldier's awareness of the blunder complicate a straightforward interpretation of the charge as a moment of heroic glory?

  • The individual within the collective

    Analyze how Tennyson introduces a solitary soldier only to dissolve him back into "the six hundred" — what implications does this have for our understanding of war and identity?

  • Duty and sacrifice

    The phrase "but to do and die" frames death as an obligation rather than a choice; explore what this reveals about Victorian attitudes toward military service.

  • Tragic irony

    The soldier is aware of the truth yet cannot act on it — how does Tennyson use this irony to evoke pathos?

The Charge of the Light Brigade

Continue

Full study guide →