Skip to content
Storgy

Oliver TwistNovel by Charles Dickens

Chapter 38: CONTAINING AN ACCOUNT OF WHAT PASSED BETWEEN MR. AND MRS. BUMBLE, AND MR. MONKS, AT THEIR NOCTURNAL INTERVIEW

38 of 53 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 38 of Oliver Twist?

On a stormy summer evening, Mr. and Mrs. Bumble, dressed in worn disguises, approach a rundown group of huts on a muddy riverbank. They pause in front of a dilapidated former factory, where a man named Monks calls down to them and lets them in through a small door. Inside, Monks guides them up a ladder to a dimly lit upper room illuminated by a single hanging lantern. Mrs. Bumble takes the lead in the negotiation, insisting that she won't share any information until Monks pays her twenty-five pounds in gold, which he eventually counts out. She then reveals that when a woman named old Sally died, she confessed to stealing something from the body of a young mother — a pledge she had pawned. Sally died holding onto the pawnbroker's duplicate ticket; Mrs. Bumble redeemed the pledge and now brings out a small kid bag containing a gold locket with two locks of hair, a plain gold wedding ring, and the engraved name "Agnes" with a blank space for a surname and a date. Monks, pleased that this is what he was looking for, ties the locket to a heavy weight and drops it through a trap door into the rushing river below. He warns the Bumbles to stay quiet, they nod in agreement, and the couple leaves into the rain. Monks, not wanting to be alone, calls for a hidden boy to come back with him to the upper chamber.

Analysis

The chapter creates a persistent atmosphere of Gothic menace. Dickens begins with a detailed landscape description—an overcast sky, driving rain, a swamp, crumbling hovels, and a half-sunken factory—that serves as a moral compass: the physical decay around them reflects the corruption of the forthcoming transaction. The building is personified ("seemed to wait a favourable opportunity of following its old companion"), granting it a conspiratorial quality that aligns with Monks's devious nature.

The point of view stays in close third-person, but the narrator's irony is cutting: Mr. Bumble's cowardice is repeatedly undermined by mock-heroic phrases ("remarkable dignity," "very determined officer," "melancholy feint of grasping his lantern with fierce determination"), while Mrs. Bumble's calm competence is described with a straight-faced admiration that makes her husband appear even more foolish.

The chapter unfolds as a negotiation in three parts: arrival and intimidation, bargaining, and revelation followed by destruction. The trap-door serves as the chapter's central image: it first poses a threat (Monks's warning not to move), then reveals (the rushing river below), and finally destroys (when the locket is dropped in). Water—rain, river, the rushing current—pervades every scene, connecting the storm outside to the moral chaos within and culminating in the disappearance of evidence.

Monks's outbursts and his fear of thunder add a layer of psychological instability that intensifies his threat. His face, much distorted and discoloured when he uncovers it after the thunder, makes him appear monstrous before the bargaining has even begun.

Key quotes from Chapter 38

  • “Not all the rain that ever fell, or ever will fall, will put as much of hell’s fire out, as a man can carry about with him.”

    Monks addresses Mr. Bumble sarcastically after Bumble stammers that the couple were only cooling themselves outside in the rain.

  • “Such matters keep well, and, like good wine, often double their value in course of time”

    Mrs. Bumble coolly defends the worth of her secret to Monks when he protests that it has been "lying dead for twelve years past or more."

  • “If the sea ever gives up its dead, as books say it will, it will keep its gold and silver to itself, and that trash among it.”

    Monks speaks after closing the trap-door, having just dropped the locket and wedding ring into the river below.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why do Mr. and Mrs. Bumble wear old, shabby outer garments on their way to meet Monks?
  2. 02What physical symptom does Monks display after a peal of thunder shakes the building?
  3. 03What price does Mrs. Bumble demand before she will reveal her secret to Monks?
  4. 04What objects does the small kid bag contain when Mrs. Bumble hands it to Monks?
  5. 05How does Monks dispose of the locket and ring at the end of the meeting?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in

Vocabulary in Chapter 38

1 word from this chapter, defined in the sense Oliver Twist uses.

facetiousness
A playful, joking manner; the quality of being witty or amusing in a light, teasing way; here used to describe a clumsy attempt at a joke.

All vocabulary in Oliver Twist →