What happens in Part III, Chapter Nine of Madame Bovary?
Immediately after Emma's death, Charles collapses onto her body, weeping, and has to be pulled away by Homais and Canivet. Homais rushes back to his shop to write letters, concoct a cover story about arsenic being mistaken for sugar, and prepare a piece for the Fanal. When he returns, he finds Charles in a daze. Eventually, Charles writes down his wishes for Emma's burial: her wedding dress, white shoes, a wreath, her hair cascading over her shoulders, three coffins nested together made of oak, mahogany, and lead, topped with a large piece of green velvet. When Homais protests about the cost, Charles angrily brushes him off. The priest walks with Charles in the garden, encouraging him to submit to God; Charles responds with blasphemous remarks. That evening, Charles watches the Hirondelle arrive, then collapses onto a mattress and falls asleep. During the night vigil, Homais and Bournisien sit with the body, endlessly debating religion, prayer, Jesuits, celibacy, and the confessional, often dozing off between arguments. Charles keeps going back upstairs, drawn to Emma's body; he recalls memories of her and finally lifts her veil, crying out in horror. Homais snips locks of her hair. At dawn, the two men eat, drink brandy, and share an unexpected moment of camaraderie. The coffin is nailed shut and set outside. Old Rouault arrives and faints in the Place upon seeing the black cloth.
Analysis
The chapter presents a series of contrasts and ironies that amplify the tragedy of Emma's death. Charles's raw, inarticulate grief—shown through fragmented sentences, repetitive phrases ("Monsieur Tuvache passing!"), and a final scream of horror—stands in stark contrast to Homais's busy self-importance: he has letters to write, a lie to concoct, and a newspaper article to prepare before he even thinks of returning to the grieving husband. This contrast highlights how grief is something the surrounding world cannot seem to accommodate.
The vigil scene serves as the chapter's darkly comedic heart. Homais and Bournisien, who represent opposing ideologies, debate prayer, the Jesuits, priestly celibacy, and the confessional—but they both keep dozing off. The chapter’s most striking image depicts them "with protruding stomachs, puffed-up faces, and frowning looks… uniting at last in the same human weakness… they moved no more than the corpse by their side." In this moment, the living and the dead are brought down to the same stillness.
In contrast to this absurdity, Charles's solitary reflection on Emma carries a genuine lyrical depth. In the section where Emma seems to spread beyond herself into the silence, the night and the passing wind, she merges with the natural world, while Charles's rush of memories of the garden at Tostes, the streets of Rouen and the yard at Bertaux captures his loss through a vivid cascade of sensory details. The chapter concludes with a sudden shift to the mechanical: hammering, nailing, soldering, and ultimately old Rouault fainting at the sight of the black cloth—grief returns to its most physical, wordless expression.
Key quotes from Part III, Chapter Nine
“they moved no more than the corpse by their side, that seemed to be sleeping.”
The narrator's summary of Homais and Bournisien after they have both fallen asleep during the night vigil beside Emma's body.
“she blended confusedly with everything around her--the silence, the night, the passing wind, the damp odours rising from the ground.”
Charles's perception of Emma during his final solitary contemplation of her body by candlelight.
“I wish her to be buried in her wedding-dress, with white shoes, and a wreath. Her hair is to be spread out over her shoulders.”
Charles's written instructions for Emma's burial, composed alone in his consulting-room.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign inVocabulary in Part III, Chapter Nine
- superfetation
- Something added unnecessarily on top of something that already exists; an excess or redundant addition, used here to mean the velvet is an unnecessary extravagance.
- ecclesiastical
- Related to the church or clergy; belonging to or characteristic of the formal structures and officials of an organized religion.