What happens in Chapter XLIII of Great Expectations?
Pip begins the chapter wrestling with his conflicting feelings about Provis (Magwitch) and Estella, choosing not to bring up Estella during his talks with Provis. He tells Herbert he needs to visit both Estella and Miss Havisham before he heads abroad. When he stops by Mrs. Brandley's in Richmond, he learns that Estella has gone to Satis House and might be gone for a while—an ambiguous answer that leaves him feeling uneasy as he makes his way home. After another late-night conversation, he and Herbert decide to keep their travel plans secret until Pip returns from his visit with Miss Havisham. To cover his trip, Pip lies to Provis, telling him he's off to see Joe. He sets out on the early morning coach and arrives at the Blue Boar inn, where he unexpectedly encounters Bentley Drummle. The two find themselves in a tense, almost ridiculous standoff at the coffee-room fireplace, trading sharp remarks and refusing to back down. Drummle makes pointed comments about dining with "the lady" and tells the waiter that the lady won't be riding today and that he will dine at the lady's, clearly mocking Pip with a sense of victory. The confrontation only ends when three farmers crowd around the fire, pushing both men apart. As Drummle leaves, Pip notices a man in a dust-coloured coat who lights Drummle's cigar; the man's slumped shoulders and unkempt hair remind Pip of Orlick. Feeling too disheartened to eat, Pip heads to Satis House.
Analysis
The chapter revolves around contrasts and parallels that reflect Pip's mental state. It begins with a self-reflective moment where Pip questions why he should "pause" or "loiter," only to dismiss his own inquiries. This establishes a tone of restless, guilty self-awareness that influences everything that follows. The journey itself is depicted through a vivid simile: the new day comes "creeping on, halting and whimpering and shivering, and wrapped in patches of cloud and rags of mist, like a beggar," projecting Pip's own despair onto the scenery.
The confrontation with Drummle at the fireplace serves as the chapter's comedic and dramatic highlight. Dickens crafts it as a series of nearly identical exchanges—mirrored nudges, the same "Can't say" responses, and simultaneous gazes at their boots—that reduce the two men to absurdity while keeping the emotional tension high. The fire becomes a symbol of masculine pride, and the poker in Pip's hand is a barely concealed threat. Drummle's repeated references to "the lady" act as a rhetorical weapon: he never names Estella, yet each mention deepens the wound. Pip's reluctance to speak her name ("which I could not endure to hear him utter") demonstrates how completely she dominates him, even in her absence.
The chapter wraps up with a foreboding, partially glimpsed detail: the figure who lights Drummle's cigar bears "slouching shoulders and ragged hair," evoking thoughts of Orlick for Pip. The uncertainty—"I could not have said from where"—casts a shadow of menace without providing clarity, and Pip's exhaustion hinders him from acting on his suspicions.
Key quotes from Chapter XLIII
“the day came creeping on, halting and whimpering and shivering, and wrapped in patches of cloud and rags of mist, like a beggar.”
Pip describes the dawn as his early morning coach travels through the open country toward Miss Havisham's.
“I felt inclined to take him in my arms (as the robber in the story-book is said to have taken the old lady) and seat him on the fire.”
Pip describes his fury at Drummle's insolent triumphant glance during their standoff at the coffee-room fireplace.
“the slouching shoulders and ragged hair of this man whose back was towards me reminded me of Orlick.”
Pip watches from the window as a man in a dust-coloured dress lights Drummle's cigar before Drummle rides away.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in