Skip to content
Storgy

A Tale of Two CitiesNovel by Charles Dickens

Chapter 42: Darkness

42 of 45 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 42 of A Tale of Two Cities?

Sydney Carton stands in a dimly lit street in Paris, determined that the Defarges should know he’s in the city. He locates Defarge's wine shop in Saint Antoine, then dines at an eating place elsewhere and sleeps, taking no strong drink for the first time in years. He wakes at seven, tidies himself in a shop mirror, and walks into the wine shop, where Jacques Three, the Defarges, and The Vengeance are gathered. Carton orders wine in his halting French, and Madame Defarge notes his resemblance to Evrémonde. Pretending to read a Jacobin journal, he overhears Madame Defarge announce her plan to wipe out the entire Evrémonde line and reveals that the peasant family mentioned in Doctor Manette's prison paper is her own. She dismisses her husband's plea for caution, stating she cannot be told to stop, like wind and fire. Carton leaves, momentarily tempted to confront Madame Defarge, then heads to Mr. Lorry's room at Tellson's. There, he learns that Doctor Manette has been missing since four o'clock. They wait until midnight, when the Doctor returns—broken, asking for his shoemaking bench, and completely relapsed. Carton takes charge: he finds a certificate in the Doctor's coat that permits Manette, Lucie, and her child to leave France. He gives Mr. Lorry his own exit certificate for safekeeping, warns him that Madame Defarge intends to denounce Lucie, and outlines a clear escape plan—horses ready by two o'clock, the carriage to leave as soon as Carton arrives. He says goodbye to Mr. Lorry, helps guide the shattered Doctor to Lucie's courtyard, glances up at her lit window, and breathes a blessing and farewell before walking away.

Analysis

The chapter takes us on a descent into darkness—both literal and figurative—starting from the street at dusk, passing through a sinister wine-shop, leading to Doctor Manette's midnight collapse, and concluding with a silent farewell in a courtyard. The first half is seen through Carton's eyes: the reader only knows what he observes, creating dramatic irony as Madame Defarge and her companions speak openly, unaware of being watched. His actions—the slow finger tracing the journal, the "very indifferent French," the confused counting of change—reveal a study in controlled deception, highlighting the contrast between his outward passivity and inner alertness ("the listener could feel how white she was, without seeing her").

The chapter's main theme is the unstoppable force of vengeance, personified in Madame Defarge's retort that her husband may tell the wind and the fire where to stop, but not her. When she reveals that the Evrémonde victims are her own family, she shifts from a political zealot to a figure of personal sorrow, infusing her wrath with a tragic dimension while still condemning innocents. In contrast, Defarge's "weak minority" of compassion is clearly overruled.

The Doctor's relapse is portrayed through vivid physical details—the dropped coat, the bare head and throat, the swaying figure—rather than through explanation, making the moment feel immediate. Carton's reaction serves as the chapter's tonal shift: while others are frozen in grief, he responds with quiet authority. His final act, breathing "a blessing towards it, and a Farewell" at Lucie's window, brings the chapter to a close with a sense of hushed, self-sacrificing tenderness.

Key quotes from Chapter 42

  • “tell Wind and Fire where to stop,” returned madame; “but don’t tell me.”

    Madame Defarge's final retort to her husband after revealing that the Evrémonde victims are her own family and declaring her intent to exterminate the entire race.

  • ““Where is my bench? I have been looking everywhere for my bench, and I can’t find it. What have they done with my work? Time presses: I must finish those shoes.””

    Doctor Manette's words on returning to Mr. Lorry's room at midnight, showing his complete mental relapse.

  • “I have overheard words of that woman’s, to-night, which have presented their danger to me in strong colours.”

    Carton explaining to Mr. Lorry how he learned of Madame Defarge's plan to denounce Lucie and her family.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Carton abstain from strong drink in this chapter?
  2. 02What does Madame Defarge reveal about her personal connection to the Evrémonde case?
  3. 03What important document does Carton find in Doctor Manette's coat?
  4. 04What does Carton instruct Mr. Lorry to have ready by two o'clock in the afternoon?
  5. 05How does Carton learn that Madame Defarge plans to denounce Lucie?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in

Vocabulary in Chapter 42

1 word from this chapter, defined in the sense A Tale of Two Cities uses.

pacifically
In a calm, peaceable manner, without aggression or hostility.

All vocabulary in A Tale of Two Cities →