Skip to content
Storgy

A Tale of Two CitiesNovel by Charles Dickens

Chapter 17: A Companion Picture

17 of 45 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 17 of A Tale of Two Cities?

Late at night—or maybe early in the morning—after Sydney Carton has spent several nights working through Mr. Stryver's pile of legal papers, Stryver calls for another bowl of punch and announces his plans to get married, and not for money. He won't reveal the woman's name until he first criticizes Carton for being gloomy, sullen, and unpleasant in social situations, especially at Doctor Manette's house. He then lets slip that the woman is Miss Manette, reminding Carton that he once called her "a golden-haired doll" in a dismissive tone. Stryver presents the engagement as a lucky break for Lucie, pointing out his own rising career and independence as her main advantages. Carton reacts to the news with flat, indifferent comments, drinking the punch by bumpers at a great rate. Stryver then shifts the topic to Carton's future, cautioning him that he lives recklessly, doesn’t appreciate the value of money, and will eventually find himself sick and broke. He suggests that Carton should seek out a respectable woman with a little property—"somebody in the landlady way, or lodging-letting way"—and marry her as a sensible precaution. Carton's only response is, "I'll think of it."

Analysis

The chapter unfolds as a one-sided conversation, with Stryver doing most of the talking while Carton retreats into curt, evasive responses and several drinks from the punch bowl. The immediate physical difference between the two men is striking: Stryver lounges on the sofa with his hands in his waistband, looking portly and comfortable, while Carton is described as being in "a very damaged condition," removing his wet towel-turban after a long night of hard work. This physical contrast reflects the social disparity that Stryver keeps emphasizing: Stryver boasts that he gets on in the world, while Carton calls himself incorrigible.

Stryver's self-importance is a recurring theme: he constantly squares his shoulders, pumps himself up, and speaks with "ostentatious friendliness," gestures that the narrator undercuts with dry irony — his patronage "made him look twice as big as he was, and four times as offensive." The punch bowl acts as a structural marker: Carton prepares it, drinks from it using bumpers, and even uses it as a shield, responding to Stryver's questions with rhetorical counter-questions while he keeps drinking and looking at his complacent friend.

The tone subtly shifts when Stryver mentions Miss Manette. Carton's replies become shorter and more mechanical — "Why should I be astonished?" / "Why should I not approve?" — a parallelism that indicates suppressed emotions rather than indifference. The chapter concludes with Stryver's patronizing suggestion that Carton marry a landlady "against a rainy day," reducing the idea of romantic life to financial practicality and contradicting the chapter's earlier claim of a marriage "not for money."

Key quotes from Chapter 17

  • “I have no business to be, at all, that I know of,” said Sydney Carton.”

    Carton responds to Stryver's insistence that he has no business being incorrigible, turning the rebuke into a bleak self-dismissal.

  • “The prosperous patronage with which he said it, made him look twice as big as he was, and four times as offensive.”

    The narrator's aside after Stryver advises Carton to find a nurse and think about his future.

  • “Find out some respectable woman with a little property--somebody in the landlady way, or lodging-letting way--and marry her, against a rainy day.”

    Stryver's closing advice to Carton about how he ought to secure his future.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why has Carton been working so many consecutive nights at the start of the chapter?
  2. 02What method has Carton been using to keep himself alert through the long working nights?
  3. 03How does Stryver describe Carton's behaviour at Doctor Manette's house?
  4. 04What dismissive phrase had Carton previously used to describe Miss Manette, according to Stryver?
  5. 05What type of woman does Stryver recommend Carton should marry?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in