The Annotated Edition
Summer by James Russell Lowell
A man recalls a young woman bidding him farewell at a garden gate, using the German phrase "Auf wiedersehen" — which means "until we meet again" — rather than a simple English goodbye.
- Core theme
- Loneliness
Study actions
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
The little gate was reached at last, / Half hid in lilacs down the lane;
Editor's note
We begin with a poignant parting scene. The gate is nestled in a lane lined with lilacs — a private, almost hidden place. The woman pushes it open, glances back, and says *Auf wiedersehen* — which means "until we meet again" in German. That look over her shoulder reveals it all: she doesn’t want to leave, but she does.
With hand on latch, a vision white / Lingered reluctant, and again
Editor's note
She pauses at the gate, called a "vision white" — wearing light clothing that makes her look almost ghostly in the evening light. The word *reluctant* carries a lot of weight here; she hesitates, unsure if she should say it again. When she finally does, the repetition of *Auf wiedersehen* feels softer and more intimate, like dew falling at night.
The lamp's clear gleam flits up the stair; / I linger in delicious pain;
Editor's note
Now we’re inside the speaker’s head as he watches her lamp rise through the house. “Delicious pain” perfectly captures romantic longing—it hurts, yet he craves more of it. He wonders, questioning with *Auf wiedersehen*, if she’s thinking of him too as she heads to her room.
'Tis thirteen years; once more I press / The turf that silences the lane;
Editor's note
A sudden leap forward: thirteen years have gone by. He finds himself back at the same lane, walking the same ground. The phrase "silences the lane" feels oddly haunting — the grass softens his steps, and the lane seems quiet, as if it's holding its breath. Then the memories come rushing back: her dress, the lilacs, and her voice whispering goodbye.
Sweet piece of bashful maiden art! / The English words had seemed too fain,
Editor's note
In the final stanza, the speaker takes a moment to think about *why* she chose German over English. "Too fain" translates to too eager or too forward. Using straightforward English phrases like "goodbye" or "until we meet again" would have felt too blunt, too openly optimistic. The foreign phrase allowed her to express tenderness while maintaining a sense of decorum between them — it brought them closer while still keeping things proper.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- The lilacs
- Lilacs symbolize first love and memories in 19th-century poetry. In this case, their scent transports the speaker back over thirteen years more vividly than any visual detail could.
- The gate
- The gate represents the divide between togetherness and separation. She pushes it open and steps through, a tangible act of leaving. Her hand lingers on the latch, revealing her hesitation to completely cross that line.
- *Auf wiedersehen*
- The German phrase — which translates to "until we see each other again" — serves as the emotional heart of the poem. It's a promise cloaked in politeness. Since it’s in a foreign language, it evokes deep feelings while still adhering to the social decorum expected of a young woman in the 1800s.
- The lamp climbing the stair
- The moving lamp is the final reminder of her presence that the speaker can cling to. It signifies her withdrawal into her own private world, and when it finally vanishes, it truly marks the end of their time together that evening.
- The turf of the lane
- When the speaker comes back after thirteen years and "presses the turf," the ground transforms into a guardian of memories. The grass that muffles his footsteps appears to carry the echoes of what once was.
§06Form & structure
Form & structure
- Meter
- iambic tetrameter
- Rhyme
- AABBA AABBA AABBA AABBA AABBA
§07Historical context
Historical context
§08FAQ
Questions readers ask
What does 'Auf wiedersehen' mean and why does she say it in German?
Auf wiedersehen is German for "until we meet again" or "until we see each other again." In the final stanza, the speaker reflects that saying the same thing in English would have seemed "too fain" — too eager, too openly romantic. By using a foreign phrase, she could convey genuine feelings while maintaining a bit of distance through the formality of another language. It was a subtle, clever way to protect her emotions.
What happened between the speaker and the woman? Are they in love?
Lowell never makes it explicit, which adds to the poem's charm. The details — the hesitant farewell, the "delicious pain," the thirteen years of cherished memories — suggest a young love that was either never fully expressed or never fully experienced. It's unclear whether they separated due to circumstances, choice, or something more definitive, leaving it open to interpretation.
Why does the speaker return after thirteen years?
The poem leaves out certain details, and that silence is intentional. What’s important is that when he comes back, the place brings back such strong sensory memories that he can hear her voice and smell the lilacs. The thirteen-year gap only makes that memory feel even more vivid.
What does 'delicious pain' mean in the third stanza?
It's Lowell's way of expressing that bittersweet longing—it's that ache you almost cherish because it shows how much you truly care. The speaker stands in the dark, observing her lamp flicker throughout the house, experiencing a mix of pleasure and pain all at once.
What is the structure and form of the poem?
The poem consists of five stanzas, each with five lines. Every stanza concludes with a variation of Auf wiedersehen, serving as a refrain. The rhyme scheme follows ABAAB, and the meter is mostly iambic tetrameter. This repeated refrain imparts a song-like, nearly hypnotic quality to the poem, reflecting how the phrase lingers in the speaker's memory.
What does 'vision white' mean in the second stanza?
It portrays the woman lingering at the gate in the evening light, wearing light or white clothing. The term "vision" serves two purposes: it captures what the speaker sees and also transforms her into an almost dreamlike figure, one that will linger in his thoughts long after she has left.
Is this poem autobiographical? Did this really happen to Lowell?
There's no specific biographical event that directly relates to the poem. While Lowell faced loss and longing in his life—his first wife, Maria White, passed away at a young age—this poem feels more like a carefully crafted lyric in the Romantic style rather than a straightforward diary entry. The "I" in the poem should be seen as a speaker, not necessarily as Lowell himself.
What does 'the turf that silences the lane' mean?
It means the grassy ground of the lane softens his footsteps as he walks. But "silences" also adds an emotional layer — the lane feels still, as if time has paused there. This creates a subtly eerie, respectful atmosphere, like stepping into a space that has been patiently awaiting someone.
Citation
Cite this poem
MLA
Lowell, James Russell. "Summer." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/summer-james-russell-lowell/.
APA
Lowell, J. R. (n.d.). Summer. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/summer-james-russell-lowell/
Row A — Thesis
1 ptIn 'SUMMER,' James Russell Lowell uses the recurring German farewell 'Auf wiedersehen' — meaning, literally, 'until we see again' — as a structural and tonal pivot to argue that longing itself is a form of love. The speaker does not mourn …
- Row B — Evidence + Commentary4 pts
- Row C — Sophistication1 pt
- Common student errors
Available on any Storgy plan — model paragraphs, band callouts, and common student errors for every poem.
The study desk
Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.
Adjacent texts in the archive
Read next
- In the same key
A Farewell
Alfred, Lord Tennyson
Read & analyze - In the same key
Neutral Tones
Thomas Hardy
Read & analyze - In the same key
The Garden of Proserpine
Algernon Charles Swinburne
Read & analyze - In the same key
La Belle Dame Sans Merci
John Keats
Read & analyze - In the same key
Annabel Lee
Edgar Allan Poe
Read & analyze