The Annotated Edition
Sin by Percy Bysshe Shelley
This poem satirizes "Peter," a representation of the poet Robert Southey, whom Shelley held in disdain.
- Core theme
- Art
Study actions
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
Lo. Peter in Hell's Grosvenor Square, / A footman in the Devil's service!
Editor's note
Shelley plunges us into Hell, cleverly presenting it as a trendy London locale — Grosvenor Square, home to the city's affluent elite. In this setting, Peter isn't a lord; he's a servant. The humor hits hard: this man who once saw himself as significant now finds himself as a footman in the Devil's domain.
But Peter, though now damned, was not / What Peter was before damnation.
Editor's note
Shelley takes a moment to acknowledge that Peter wasn't always like this. Sometimes, people find themselves in situations that clash with their true selves. This stanza introduces the notion that Peter's downfall is, in part, due to his circumstances — he was influenced by an unfavorable environment.
All things that Peter saw and felt / Had a peculiar aspect to him;
Editor's note
Peter has a unique inner world. Everything he experiences gets absorbed into his nature, merging with it like clouds coming together. This might sound like a compliment — and it partly is — but Shelley is also hinting at the issue: Peter internalizes everything, but nothing ever comes back out.
And so the outward world uniting / To that within him, he became
Editor's note
Because Peter takes everything in without sharing anything in return, he becomes unappealing to everyday people—those who don’t engage in self-reflection and simply follow the crowd. While the world and Peter have merged, it leads to his social isolation.
And he scorned them, and they scorned him;
Editor's note
A society of mutual contempt. Peter scorns the drinking, lying, swearing crowd surrounding him, and they return the disdain. Shelley points out that neither side is coming out on top.
Such were his fellow-servants; thus / His virtue, like our own, was built
Editor's note
Here Shelley turns the knife. Peter's virtue isn't genuine goodness — it's just "Hypocrite Pride," the self-righteous indignation that allows people to feel superior to others. Shelley brings himself and the reader into this ("like our own"), making it a sharp and honest move.
He had a mind which was somehow / At once circumference and centre
Editor's note
Peter's mind is portrayed as both the boundary and the heart of all his experiences — a closed system. Nothing escapes, although things can come in. It's a striking metaphor for a specific type of thinker: someone who absorbs ideas but never creates or transforms them into something that impacts the outside world.
He had as much imagination / As a pint-pot;
Editor's note
One of Shelley's most striking lines. Peter can only view the world from his own vantage point—he lacks the ability to envision things from another's perspective. A pint-pot holds exactly one pint and nothing beyond that. The comparison is both straightforward and humorous.
Yet his was individual mind, / And new created all he saw
Editor's note
Shelley adds depth to the discussion. Even without traditional imagination, Peter possesses an intense and original way of seeing things — he interprets his observations in a personal way, refines them, and mixes them together. This is a genuine intellectual talent, and Shelley recognizes it sincerely.
Thus—though unimaginative— / An apprehension clear, intense,
Editor's note
Peter's clarity of mind is genuine. He perceives and processes information with accuracy. However, Shelley describes this as a form of thought that awakens the senses instead of the soul—it's analytical intelligence, lacking the warmth and depth of true imagination.
But from the first 'twas Peter's drift / To be a kind of moral eunuch,
Editor's note
The main accusation. Peter reaches for Nature — representing life, passion, and the entire sensory and emotional experience — yet hesitates at the final moment. He brushes the hem of her dress but quickly withdraws. "Moral eunuch" captures Shelley at his harshest: Peter has severed his own ability to fully engage in authentic experiences.
She laughed the while, with an arch smile, / And kissed him with a sister's kiss,
Editor's note
Nature responds to Peter's timidity with a playful fondness — more like a sister's kiss than a lover's. She cares for him but sees through his hesitance. She points out that he's cold and reminds him that she offers love freely to those who embrace her wholeheartedly.
'Tis you are cold—for I, not coy, / Yield love for love, frank, warm, and true;
Editor's note
Nature's speech goes on, revealing everything. She references Robert Burns — a "Scottish peasant boy" who made his share of mistakes but lived life passionately — as someone who understood her joy much more than the careful, scholarly Peter ever could. The difference between Burns's vibrant spirit and Peter's detached intellect lies at the core of Shelley's argument.
'Boeca bacciata non perde ventura, / Anzi rinnuova come fa la luna:
Editor's note
Nature quotes Boccaccio in Italian: "A kissed mouth loses no savour, but renews itself like the moon." This suggests that love and physical experiences don’t take away from you; instead, they refresh you. Shelley uses this quote to pinpoint Peter's issue as a "low-tide in soul," indicating a stagnation brought on by his unwillingness to connect.
Then Peter rubbed his eyes severe. / And smoothed his spacious forehead down
Editor's note
Peter stirs from a dream, feeling a mix of confusion, love, and fear, and simply sits back down. The way he smooths his forehead brings a sense of relief; it's his way of grappling with a vision of Nature herself, even if it leaves him a bit uneasy.
The Devil was no uncommon creature; / A leaden-witted thief—just huddled
Editor's note
Now Shelley turns to the Devil, Peter's employer, and the portrait is intentionally underwhelming. This Devil isn't grand or terrifying — he's dull, heavy, toad-like, and muddled in thought. Shelley implies that evil isn't glamorous; it’s simply stupidity and greed wrapped in an awkward form.
He was that heavy, dull, cold thing, / The spirit of evil well may be:
Editor's note
The Devil is too lazy to even bother with stinging. He lounges around, refers to lust as "luxury," and confuses self-indulgence with sophistication. This reflects Shelley's view of evil as something mundane — not grand moral failings but rather slow, self-satisfied vice.
Now he was quite the kind of wight / Round whom collect, at a fixed aera,
Editor's note
The Devil throws extravagant dinner parties featuring venison, turtle, fine wines, and East Indian madeira. He embodies the archetype of a wealthy, influential patron, drawing in brilliant minds and reveling in their brilliance.
It was his fancy to invite / Men of science, wit, and learning,
Editor's note
The Devil believes his gold sparks the brilliance of his guests and takes pride in his salon. Yet the irony is clear: he mistakes being close to intelligence for actually having it.
And men of learning, science, wit, / Considered him as you and I
Editor's note
The knowledgeable guests perceive the Devil for what he truly is: a decayed tree that they gather beneath for shade and convenience, rather than out of reverence. They exploit him. He remains oblivious. The metaphor of the decayed tree is spot on—providing shelter, yet lifeless at its heart.
And all the while with loose fat smile, / The willing wretch sat winking there,
Editor's note
The Devil grins and winks, believing that this entire brilliant scene is all his doing. The "unnoticed chair" detail is spot-on—his seat of power goes unacknowledged by everyone else. He thinks he's the one hosting a grand gathering, but in reality, he's just another piece of furniture.
Though to be sure this place was Hell; / He was the Devil—and all they—
Editor's note
Shelley pulls back to remind us of the frame: this is Hell. The claret flows, and the wit ebbs and flows like the ocean, but everyone at the table — the Devil, Peter, the brilliant guests — is stuck in eternal damnation. The final note strikes a balance between bleakness and humor: no amount of fine wine or clever banter can alter the core reality.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- Grosvenor Square
- A genuine, stylish London address dropped into Hell. It suggests that Hell isn't just an exotic underworld but rather a reflection of the respectable, affluent English society — implying that the two aren't all that different.
- The pint-pot
- A container that holds just one fixed measure and nothing beyond that. It represents Peter's lack of imaginative empathy—his struggle to step outside his own perspective and view the world through someone else's eyes.
- Nature's shift and tunic
- Nature's clothing reflects the rich complexity of human experience—sensory, emotional, erotic, spiritual. Peter only touches the hem and never dares to lift the veil. The image reveals his deep-seated shyness in the face of real life.
- The rotten tree
- The Devil is like a dead tree that still offers shade. This imagery reflects the dynamic between corrupt power and the skilled individuals who exploit it for their own benefit, all while secretly harboring disdain for it.
- The sister's kiss
- Nature's kiss for Peter is warm and caring but clearly non-erotic. It defines the boundary of what Peter can experience from the world — warmth without depth, connection without change.
- The stagnant laguna
- Boccaccio's image, cited by Nature, reflects Peter's inner state: a low tide, still water, and no movement. This symbolizes the spiritual and creative stagnation that comes from not fully engaging with one's experiences.
§06Historical context
Historical context
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
Who is 'Peter' in this poem?
Peter serves mainly as a satirical depiction of William Wordsworth, incorporating traits of Robert Southey as well. Shelley composed the poem as a reaction to Wordsworth's Peter Bell (1819), using the character to criticize what he perceived as Wordsworth's intellectual cowardice, moral hypocrisy, and political abandonment of his previous radical beliefs.
Why is Peter in Hell?
Hell presents Shelley's metaphor for the corrupt, trendy world of English society—particularly the realm of establishment power and comfortable conformity. Peter is "damned" not for committing grand sins, but because he opted for safety, pride, and cold respectability instead of truly engaging with life and truth.
What does Shelley mean by calling Peter a 'moral eunuch'?
It's one of Shelley's sharpest phrases. He suggests that Peter has chosen to disconnect from the richness of life — the passion, risk, and emotional and sensory experiences. He comes close to embracing Nature (which represents fully lived experience) but always hesitates and retreats. He can feel deeply but chooses not to act on those feelings.
Why does Shelley bring up Robert Burns?
Burns stands in stark contrast to Peter. He was a Scottish poet from a working-class background whose life was filled with what polite society would label as "mistakes" — drinking, illegitimate children, and romantic escapades. However, Nature (as personified in the poem) suggests that Burns understood her joy much more deeply than the learned and cautious Peter. Shelley is making the case that a real, albeit messy and imperfect, engagement with life is far superior to the cold, intellectual respectability that Peter represents.
What is the Italian quotation in stanza 14?
It's a line from Boccaccio's Decameron: "A kissed mouth loses no savour, but renews itself like the moon." Shelley has Nature quote this to emphasize that love and experience don’t take away from you — they actually restore you. It's a clear challenge to Peter's uptight views.
Is the Devil in this poem supposed to be scary?
Deliberately not. Shelley's Devil comes off as dull, fat, toad-like, and stupid — too lazy even to sting. He’s a corrupt rich patron who hosts dinner parties, confusing his wealth with intelligence. The takeaway is that evil isn’t glamorous or powerful; it’s simply mundane greed and self-satisfaction. This foreshadows what Hannah Arendt would later describe as the "banality of evil."
What is the poem's overall argument about virtue?
Shelley argues that what is often seen as virtue in respectable society is really just "Hypocrite Pride" — the self-righteous disdain people hold for others' shortcomings, allowing them to feel superior without actually being good. For Shelley, true virtue demands authentic imaginative empathy and a complete engagement with life, qualities that Peter does not possess.
Why does the poem end on such a bleak note?
The final stanza serves as a stark reminder that regardless of the quality of the wine or the brilliance of the conversation, everyone at the Devil's table is doomed for eternity. Shelley's message is clear: wit and culture can't save a corrupt system — they merely make it more bearable. The claret and the engaging dialogue are enjoyable, but they don't alter the underlying reality.
Citation
Cite this poem
MLA
Shelley, Percy Bysshe. "Sin." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/sin-percy-bysshe-shelley/.
APA
Shelley, P. B. (n.d.). Sin. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/sin-percy-bysshe-shelley/
Row A — Thesis
1 ptIn 'SIN.' Percy Bysshe Shelley employs the mock-heroic damnation of Peter Bell to reveal the self-defeating nature of moralistic pride, arguing that a virtue cloaked in contempt and lacking genuine imaginative sympathy has social effects …
- Row B — Evidence + Commentary4 pts
- Row C — Sophistication1 pt
- Common student errors
Available on any Storgy plan — model paragraphs, band callouts, and common student errors for every poem.
The study desk
Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.
Adjacent texts in the archive
Read next
- In the same key
The Dunciad
Alexander Pope
Read & analyze - In the same key
Epistle to Dr Arbuthnot
Alexander Pope
Read & analyze - Modernist · 1915
The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock
T. S. Eliot
Read & analyze - In the same key
Ode to a Nightingale
John Keats
Read & analyze - In the same key
Resolution and Independence
William Wordsworth
Read & analyze - In the same key
Tintern Abbey
William Wordsworth
Read & analyze