The Annotated Edition
PRELIMINARY MOTE by James Russell Lowell
This isn't a poem; it's a mock-editorial preface—a humorous piece that Lowell crafted to introduce a series of satirical "spirit-rapped" Latin verses, which are said to be dictated by a deceased minister through the antics of a college student.
- Themes
- art, doubt, identity
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
In the month of February, 1866, the editors of the 'Atlantic Monthly' received from the Rev. Mr. Hitchcock of Jaalam a letter…
Editor's note
Lowell begins by adopting the voice of an Atlantic Monthly editor who has received a letter from a fictional clergyman, Rev. Hitchcock, hailing from the imaginary town of Jaalam. This mock-journalistic framing sets up the first layer of the humor, as it parodies the sincere editorial notes that genuine magazines of the time employed to validate unconventional contributions.
'They were rapped out on the evening of Thursday last past,' he says, 'by what claimed to be the spirit of my late predecessor…'
Editor's note
Hitchcock recounts a table-rapping séance — a real sensation in 1860s America — where the ghost of a former minister supposedly dictated Latin verses. Lowell pokes fun at Spiritualism by showing a clergyman approaching it with cautious neutrality instead of outright dismissal, subtly critiquing the wishy-washy indecisiveness of respectable society.
The table is an ordinary quadrupedal one, weighing about thirty pounds, three feet seven inches and a half in height…
Editor's note
This is the comic centerpiece of the preface. Hitchcock details the séance table with the exactness of a legal deposition—its weight, dimensions, and wood type—almost as if its everyday nature is meant to validate something. The humor lies in the fact that the more he meticulously describes it, the more ridiculous the entire endeavor appears.
On a sudden the rappings, as they are called, commenced to render themselves audible…
Editor's note
The bureaucratic language ('commenced to render themselves audible') serves as a continuous stylistic joke. Lowell is poking fun at how educated Victorians often obscured nonsense with the guise of precise observation and scientific objectivity.
So far Mr. Hitchcock, who seems perfectly master of Webster's unabridged quarto…
Editor's note
Here, the 'editor' voice playfully pokes fun at Hitchcock's wordy style — a man who has clearly read the dictionary and plans to use every word in it. This layer, where one fictional character comments on another, adds depth to the satire.
We have since learned that the young man he speaks of was a sophomore, put under his care during a sentence of rustication…
Editor's note
The reveal: the 'medium' turns out to be a college student who’s more into breaking windows than hitting the books. The professor's dry comment—that some earlier corporal punishment might have actually improved the quality and quantity of the verses—is the funniest line in the piece.
Though entirely satisfied that the verses are altogether unworthy of Mr. Wilbur… yet we have determined to print them here…
Editor's note
The editors conclude by acknowledging that the verses are poor yet choose to publish them as a warning to the student. This is Lowell's last playful nod: the intricate setup of reverends, professors, and footnotes is all meant to present a purposely subpar Latin parody, and everyone in the mix is aware of this.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- The table
- The séance table, detailed with an almost comical level of bureaucratic accuracy, represents the entire Spiritualist movement — mundane, homely, and completely unmagical, yet seen by believers as a gateway to the supernatural.
- The rusticated sophomore
- The student who was expelled for breaking windows embodies youthful mischief cloaked in spiritual mystery. He is the true 'spirit' behind the verses — human, bored, and pulling a prank.
- The birch rod
- The professor's mention of birch (a switch used for corporal punishment) represents traditional discipline and strictness, highlighting the difference from the lenient modern attitude that let the student's prank thrive.
- Latin verse
- The macaronic Latin poetry that is said to be dictated by the ghost of a dead minister reflects the pretensions of New England's scholarly culture, using classical learning to add weight to what is essentially just a schoolboy joke.
- Rev. Dr. Wilbur
- The fictional deceased minister serves as Lowell's ongoing satirical voice in the *Biglow Papers* series. In this context, his ghost represents the burden of respected tradition that the living take advantage of and ridicule.
§06Historical context
Historical context
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
Read next