PEACE! by Amy Lowell: Summary, Meaning & Analysis
PEACE!
The poem
The Bombardment Slowly, without force, the rain drops into the city. It stops a moment on the carved head of Saint John, then slides on again, slipping and trickling over his stone cloak. It splashes from the lead conduit of a gargoyle, and falls from it in turmoil on the stones in the Cathedral square. Where are the people, and why does the fretted steeple sweep about in the sky? Boom! The sound swings against the rain. Boom, again! After it, only water rushing in the gutters, and the turmoil from the spout of the gargoyle. Silence. Ripples and mutters. Boom! The room is damp, but warm. Little flashes swarm about from the firelight. The lustres of the chandelier are bright, and clusters of rubies leap in the bohemian glasses on the 'etagere'. Her hands are restless, but the white masses of her hair are quite still. Boom! Will it never cease to torture, this iteration! Boom! The vibration shatters a glass on the 'etagere'. It lies there, formless and glowing, with all its crimson gleams shot out of pattern, spilled, flowing red, blood-red. A thin bell-note pricks through the silence. A door creaks. The old lady speaks: "Victor, clear away that broken glass." "Alas! Madame, the bohemian glass!" "Yes, Victor, one hundred years ago my father brought it--" Boom! The room shakes, the servitor quakes. Another goblet shivers and breaks. Boom! It rustles at the window-pane, the smooth, streaming rain, and he is shut within its clash and murmur. Inside is his candle, his table, his ink, his pen, and his dreams. He is thinking, and the walls are pierced with beams of sunshine, slipping through young green. A fountain tosses itself up at the blue sky, and through the spattered water in the basin he can see copper carp, lazily floating among cold leaves. A wind-harp in a cedar-tree grieves and whispers, and words blow into his brain, bubbled, iridescent, shooting up like flowers of fire, higher and higher. Boom! The flame-flowers snap on their slender stems. The fountain rears up in long broken spears of dishevelled water and flattens into the earth. Boom! And there is only the room, the table, the candle, and the sliding rain. Again, Boom!--Boom!--Boom! He stuffs his fingers into his ears. He sees corpses, and cries out in fright. Boom! It is night, and they are shelling the city! Boom! Boom! A child wakes and is afraid, and weeps in the darkness. What has made the bed shake? "Mother, where are you? I am awake." "Hush, my Darling, I am here." "But, Mother, something so queer happened, the room shook." Boom! "Oh! What is it? What is the matter?" Boom! "Where is Father? I am so afraid." Boom! The child sobs and shrieks. The house trembles and creaks. Boom! Retorts, globes, tubes, and phials lie shattered. All his trials oozing across the floor. The life that was his choosing, lonely, urgent, goaded by a hope, all gone. A weary man in a ruined laboratory, that is his story. Boom! Gloom and ignorance, and the jig of drunken brutes. Diseases like snakes crawling over the earth, leaving trails of slime. Wails from people burying their dead. Through the window, he can see the rocking steeple. A ball of fire falls on the lead of the roof, and the sky tears apart on a spike of flame. Up the spire, behind the lacings of stone, zigzagging in and out of the carved tracings, squirms the fire. It spouts like yellow wheat from the gargoyles, coils round the head of Saint John, and aureoles him in light. It leaps into the night and hisses against the rain. The Cathedral is a burning stain on the white, wet night. Boom! The Cathedral is a torch, and the houses next to it begin to scorch. Boom! The bohemian glass on the 'etagere' is no longer there. Boom! A stalk of flame sways against the red damask curtains. The old lady cannot walk. She watches the creeping stalk and counts. Boom!--Boom!--Boom! The poet rushes into the street, and the rain wraps him in a sheet of silver. But it is threaded with gold and powdered with scarlet beads. The city burns. Quivering, spearing, thrusting, lapping, streaming, run the flames. Over roofs, and walls, and shops, and stalls. Smearing its gold on the sky, the fire dances, lances itself through the doors, and lisps and chuckles along the floors. The child wakes again and screams at the yellow petalled flower flickering at the window. The little red lips of flame creep along the ceiling beams. The old man sits among his broken experiments and looks at the burning Cathedral. Now the streets are swarming with people. They seek shelter and crowd into the cellars. They shout and call, and over all, slowly and without force, the rain drops into the city. Boom! And the steeple crashes down among the people. Boom! Boom, again! The water rushes along the gutters. The fire roars and mutters. Boom! Lead Soldiers The nursery fire burns brightly, crackling in cheerful little explosions and trails of sparks up the back of the chimney. Miniature rockets peppering the black bricks with golden stars, as though a gala flamed a night of victorious wars. The nodding mandarin on the bookcase moves his head forward and back, slowly, and looks into the air with his blue-green eyes. He stares into the air and nods--forward and back. The red rose in his hand is a crimson splash on his yellow coat. Forward and back, and his blue-green eyes stare into the air, and he nods--nods. Tommy's soldiers march to battle, Trumpets flare and snare-drums rattle. Bayonets flash, and sabres glance-- How the horses snort and prance! Cannon drawn up in a line Glitter in the dizzy shine Of the morning sunlight. Flags Ripple colours in great jags. Red blows out, then blue, then green, Then all three--a weaving sheen Of prismed patriotism. March Tommy's soldiers, stiff and starch, Boldly stepping to the rattle Of the drums, they go to battle. Tommy lies on his stomach on the floor and directs his columns. He puts his infantry in front, and before them ambles a mounted band. Their instruments make a strand of gold before the scarlet-tunicked soldiers, and they take very long steps on their little green platforms, and from the ranks bursts the song of Tommy's soldiers marching to battle. The song jolts a little as the green platforms stick on the thick carpet. Tommy wheels his guns round the edge of a box of blocks, and places a squad of cavalry on the commanding eminence of a footstool. The fire snaps pleasantly, and the old Chinaman nods--nods. The fire makes the red rose in his hand glow and twist. Hist! That is a bold song Tommy's soldiers sing as they march along to battle. Crack! Rattle! The sparks fly up the chimney. Tommy's army's off to war-- Not a soldier knows what for. But he knows about his rifle, How to shoot it, and a trifle Of the proper thing to do When it's he who is shot through. Like a cleverly trained flea, He can follow instantly Orders, and some quick commands Really make severe demands On a mind that's none too rapid, Leaden brains tend to the vapid. But how beautifully dressed Is this army! How impressed Tommy is when at his heel All his baggage wagons wheel About the patterned carpet, and Moving up his heavy guns He sees them glow with diamond suns Flashing all along each barrel. And the gold and blue apparel Of his gunners is a joy. Tommy is a lucky boy. Boom! Boom! Ta-ra! The old mandarin nods under his purple umbrella. The rose in his hand shoots its petals up in thin quills of crimson. Then they collapse and shrivel like red embers. The fire sizzles. Tommy is galloping his cavalry, two by two, over the floor. They must pass the open terror of the door and gain the enemy encamped under the wash-stand. The mounted band is very grand, playing allegro and leading the infantry on at the double quick. The tassel of the hearth-rug has flung down the bass-drum, and he and his dapple-grey horse lie overtripped, slipped out of line, with the little lead drumsticks glistening to the fire's shine. The fire burns and crackles, and tickles the tripped bass-drum with its sparkles. The marching army hitches its little green platforms valiantly, and steadily approaches the door. The overturned bass-drummer, lying on the hearth-rug, melting in the heat, softens and sheds tears. The song jeers at his impotence, and flaunts the glory of the martial and still upstanding, vaunting the deeds it will do. For are not Tommy's soldiers all bright and new? Tommy's leaden soldiers we, Glittering with efficiency. Not a button's out of place, Tons and tons of golden lace Wind about our officers. Every manly bosom stirs At the thought of killing--killing! Tommy's dearest wish fulfilling. We are gaudy, savage, strong, And our loins so ripe we long First to kill, then procreate, Doubling so the laws of Fate. On their women we have sworn To graft our sons. And overborne They'll rear us younger soldiers, so Shall our race endure and grow, Waxing greater in the wombs Borrowed of them, while damp tombs Rot their men. O Glorious War! Goad us with your points, Great Star! The china mandarin on the bookcase nods slowly, forward and back--forward and back--and the red rose writhes and wriggles, thrusting its flaming petals under and over one another like tortured snakes. The fire strokes them with its dartles, and purrs at them, and the old man nods. Tommy does not hear the song. He only sees the beautiful, new, gaily-coloured lead soldiers. They belong to him, and he is very proud and happy. He shouts his orders aloud, and gallops his cavalry past the door to the wash-stand. He creeps over the floor on his hands and knees to one battalion and another, but he sees only the bright colours of his soldiers and the beautiful precision of their gestures. He is a lucky boy to have such fine lead soldiers to enjoy. Tommy catches his toe in the leg of the wash-stand, and jars the pitcher. He snatches at it with his hands, but it is too late. The pitcher falls, and as it goes, he sees the white water flow over its lip. It slips between his fingers and crashes to the floor. But it is not water which oozes to the door. The stain is glutinous and dark, a spark from the firelight heads it to red. In and out, between the fine, new soldiers, licking over the carpet, squirms the stream of blood, lapping at the little green platforms, and flapping itself against the painted uniforms. The nodding mandarin moves his head slowly, forward and back. The rose is broken, and where it fell is black blood. The old mandarin leers under his purple umbrella, and nods--forward and back, staring into the air with blue-green eyes. Every time his head comes forward a rosebud pushes between his lips, rushes into full bloom, and drips to the ground with a splashing sound. The pool of black blood grows and grows, with each dropped rose, and spreads out to join the stream from the wash-stand. The beautiful army of lead soldiers steps boldly forward, but the little green platforms are covered in the rising stream of blood. The nursery fire burns brightly and flings fan-bursts of stars up the chimney, as though a gala flamed a night of victorious wars. The Painter on Silk There was a man Who made his living By painting roses Upon silk. He sat in an upper chamber And painted, And the noises of the street Meant nothing to him. When he heard bugles, and fifes, and drums, He thought of red, and yellow, and white roses Bursting in the sunshine, And smiled as he worked. He thought only of roses, And silk. When he could get no more silk He stopped painting And only thought Of roses. The day the conquerors Entered the city, The old man Lay dying. He heard the bugles and drums, And wished he could paint the roses Bursting into sound. A Ballad of Footmen Now what in the name of the sun and the stars Is the meaning of this most unholy of wars? Do men find life so full of humour and joy That for want of excitement they smash up the toy? Fifteen millions of soldiers with popguns and horses All bent upon killing, because their "of courses" Are not quite the same. All these men by the ears, And nine nations of women choking with tears. It is folly to think that the will of a king Can force men to make ducks and drakes of a thing They value, and life is, at least one supposes, Of some little interest, even if roses Have not grown up between one foot and the other. What a marvel bureaucracy is, which can smother Such quite elementary feelings, and tag A man with a number, and set him to wag His legs and his arms at the word of command Or the blow of a whistle! He's certainly damned, Fit only for mince-meat, if a little gold lace And an upturned moustache can set him to face Bullets, and bayonets, and death, and diseases, Because some one he calls his Emperor, pleases. If each man were to lay down his weapon, and say, With a click of his heels, "I wish you Good-day," Now what, may I ask, could the Emperor do? A king and his minions are really so few. Angry? Oh, of course, a most furious Emperor! But the men are so many they need not mind his temper, or The dire results which could not be inflicted. With no one to execute sentence, convicted Is just the weak wind from an old, broken bellows. What lackeys men are, who might be such fine fellows! To be killing each other, unmercifully, At an order, as though one said, "Bring up the tea." Or is it that tasting the blood on their jaws They lap at it, drunk with its ferment, and laws So patiently builded, are nothing to drinking More blood, any blood. They don't notice its stinking. I don't suppose tigers do, fighting cocks, sparrows, And, as to men--what are men, when their marrows Are running with blood they have gulped; it is plain Such excellent sport does not recollect pain. Toll the bells in the steeples left standing. Half-mast The flags which meant order, for order is past. Take the dust of the streets and sprinkle your head, The civilization we've worked for is dead. Squeeze into this archway, the head of the line Has just swung round the corner to 'Die Wacht am Rhein'.
PEACE! is a collection of four poems by Amy Lowell that explore a shared theme: war lacks glory and instead embodies destruction disguised in elegant uniforms. Through imagery of a bombed cathedral, a child's toy soldiers stained with blood, a silk painter yearning to create roses, and a ballad questioning why people follow orders to die, Lowell dismantles every romantic notion of combat. By the conclusion, her tone is not hopeful — it’s filled with anger, and she wants you to feel that way too.
Line-by-line
Slowly, without force, the rain drops into the city. It stops a moment / on the carved head of Saint John...
The room is damp, but warm. Little flashes swarm about from the firelight...
It rustles at the window-pane, the smooth, streaming rain, and he is / shut within its clash and murmur...
A child wakes and is afraid, and weeps in the darkness. What has made / the bed shake?
Retorts, globes, tubes, and phials lie shattered. All his trials oozing / across the floor.
Boom! The Cathedral is a torch, and the houses next to it begin to scorch...
The poet rushes into the street, and the rain wraps him in a sheet of / silver.
The child wakes again and screams at the yellow petalled flower / flickering at the window.
The old man sits among his broken experiments and looks at the burning / Cathedral.
The nursery fire burns brightly, crackling in cheerful little explosions / and trails of sparks up the back of the chimney.
Tommy's soldiers march to battle, / Trumpets flare and snare-drums rattle.
Tommy lies on his stomach on the floor and directs his columns...
Tommy's army's off to war-- / Not a soldier knows what for.
Tommy's leaden soldiers we, / Glittering with efficiency.
Tommy does not hear the song. He only sees the beautiful, new, / gaily-coloured lead soldiers.
Tommy catches his toe in the leg of the wash-stand, and jars the pitcher...
The nodding mandarin moves his head slowly, forward and back. The rose / is broken...
There was a man / Who made his living / By painting roses / Upon silk.
The day the conquerors / Entered the city, / The old man / Lay dying.
Now what in the name of the sun and the stars / Is the meaning of this most unholy of wars?
Do men find life so full of humour and joy / That for want of excitement they smash up the toy?
Fifteen millions of soldiers with popguns and horses / All bent upon killing, because their 'of courses'
It is folly to think that the will of a king / Can force men to make ducks and drakes of a thing
If each man were to lay down his weapon, and say, / With a click of his heels, 'I wish you Good-day,'
Or is it that tasting the blood on their jaws / They lap at it, drunk with its ferment...
Toll the bells in the steeples left standing. Half-mast / The flags which meant order, for order is past.
Tone & mood
The collection shifts through various tones, and that shift is part of its power. *The Bombardment* feels cinematic and cold — Lowell observes the destruction with a journalist’s perspective, but that coldness carries a controlled rage. *Lead Soldiers* begins with warmth and playfulness, only to curdle into something truly unsettling; the nursery-rhyme sections start with a cheerful singsong that grows increasingly disturbing as the poem unfolds. *The Painter on Silk* is quiet and elegiac, almost like a pause between storms. *A Ballad of Footmen* stands out as the angriest piece in the collection — sardonic, frustrated, and ultimately mournful. Throughout these four poems, Lowell avoids sentimentality. She isn’t asking you to pity the dead; instead, she wants you to grasp the stupidity and violence of the system that led to their deaths.
Symbols & metaphors
- The Bohemian glass — The hundred-year-old glass passed down from the old lady's father represents all that civilization gathers over generations — beauty, craftsmanship, memories, and continuity. When it shatters under the bombardment, it symbolizes the breaking of that legacy. The "blood-red" spill highlights the link between destruction and death.
- The nodding mandarin — The porcelain figure on the nursery bookcase nods throughout *Lead Soldiers* with an unsettling, mechanical patience. He embodies ancient wisdom—or perhaps just a knowledge of how this story always concludes. His rose blossoms and drips blood; he observes Tommy play without a word. He represents a facet of human history that has witnessed this cycle before and understands it will repeat.
- Lead soldiers — Tommy's toy soldiers serve as the central symbol of the poem. They are beautifully painted in bright colors and made of lead—a soft, toxic metal. These toy soldiers illustrate how war is marketed to children and civilians: filled with color, pageantry, and pride, while the real dangers and consequences lie beneath the surface. The blood that eventually coats them brings this metaphor to life.
- Roses — Roses appear throughout all four poems — in the mandarin's hand, in the painter's imagination, and in a casual mention in the ballad. They represent beauty, art, and the everyday life that war devastates. The painter hears bugles and thinks of roses; this connection is both his talent and his means of coping. When the mandarin's rose transforms into black blood, the symbol shifts into its opposite.
- The Cathedral — The Cathedral in *The Bombardment* stands as civilization's greatest achievement—sacred, ancient, and communal. Its burning symbolizes more than mere physical destruction; it signifies the loss of the shared values and history it embodies. The fire engulfing the spire and enveloping Saint John in flames offers a grotesque mockery of consecration.
- Rain — The rain opens and closes *The Bombardment*, falling "slowly, without force" all the while. It remains indifferent to everything—the bombing, the burning, the dying. It doesn't pause for human tragedy. Lowell employs it to convey the universe's complete indifference to human actions, which feels more unsettling than any outright malevolence could.
Historical context
Amy Lowell published *PEACE!* in 1916, two years into the First World War. At that point, America had yet to join the fight, but the war was the main topic of discussion everywhere. Lowell — a Boston Brahmin, an Imagist poet, and a woman with strong opinions — observed Europe tearing itself apart with a blend of horror and anger. The Imagist movement, which she had introduced to American readers after her encounter with Ezra Pound in London, valued precise, concrete imagery over abstract concepts. You can see this influence throughout *The Bombardment* and *Lead Soldiers* — Lowell doesn't just tell you that war is terrible; she depicts a child mistaking fire for a flower. In *A Ballad of Footmen*, she shifts from Imagism to direct argument, reflecting her deep frustration. This collection aligns with other anti-war literature of the time — such as the works of Siegfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen — but Lowell's perspective comes from the civilian home front rather than the trenches, offering a unique view: she observes how war affects the world that people actually inhabit.
FAQ
Lowell argues throughout all four poems that war isn't heroic, necessary, or inevitable. Instead, it's a shared act of foolishness driven by those in power and made possible by the compliance of ordinary people. The title carries a bitter irony; these poems reveal no peace, only the devastation of everything that peace creates.
The title is sarcastic. Lowell highlights the disconnect between the ideals that war is meant to protect—peace, civilization, order—and the reality it creates. The exclamation mark gives it a sense of urgency or a shout, rather than simply describing something found in the poems.
World War One started in 1914. The final line of *A Ballad of Footmen* alludes to *Die Wacht am Rhein*, a German nationalist anthem, linking the poem to that conflict. Lowell penned the collection in 1916, during a time when America maintained its neutrality.
Tommy represents an archetypal English boy — "Tommy" was slang for a British soldier, which adds to the significance. The child playing with toy soldiers symbolizes the future soldier destined for conflict. His innocence and joy highlight the disturbing reality of how early militaristic conditioning takes root, as shown by Lowell.
The porcelain mandarin stands as a quiet, ancient observer. He nods during *Lead Soldiers*, as if he's witnessed it all before and knows how it concludes. His rose eventually bleeds black, hinting that beauty and life often fall victim to the cycle he's seen play out over centuries.
The painter has devoted his entire inner life to beauty. Even when the material conditions for his art are stripped away—like silk—his imagination doesn't falter. He continues to envision roses because that’s simply who he is. Lowell portrays this as both admirable and tragic: the creative spirit endures despite the world that should support it being torn apart.
Yes, that's the gist of it. Lowell argues that if every soldier just said "Good day" and walked away, no emperor could do anything to stop them. She's advocating for collective refusal — the strength of the many outweighing the few. She also questions why men don’t take this action, suggesting reasons that range from bureaucratic conditioning to the allure of violence itself.
Imagism was an early 20th-century poetry movement that prioritized sharp, concrete images instead of vague romantic language. In *The Bombardment*, rather than stating "war is terrible," Lowell presents a scene where a child confuses fire for a flower and an old woman counts shell blasts because she can’t walk to safety. This imagery conveys the emotional weight more powerfully than a simple statement could. On the other hand, *A Ballad of Footmen* takes a more direct approach, which is why its texture feels distinct from the other three poems.