ON PLANTING A TREE AT INVERARAY by James Russell Lowell: Summary, Meaning & Analysis
A man plants a tree and questions if that one act fulfills his duty in life.
The poem
Who does his duty is a question Too complex to be solved by me, But he, I venture the suggestion, Does part of his that plants a tree. For after he is dead and buried, And epitaphed, and well forgot, Nay, even his shade by Charon ferried To--let us not inquire to what, His deed, its author long outliving, By Nature's mother-care increased, Shall stand, his verdant almoner, giving A kindly dole to man and beast. The wayfarer, at noon reposing, Shall bless its shadow on the grass, Or sheep beneath it huddle, dozing Until the thundergust o'erpass. The owl, belated in his plundering, Shall here await the friendly night, Blinking whene'er he wakes, and wondering What fool it was invented light. Hither the busy birds shall flutter, With the light timber for their nests, And, pausing from their labor, utter The morning sunshine in their breasts. What though his memory shall have vanished, Since the good deed he did survives? It is not wholly to be banished Thus to be part of many lives. Grow, then, my foster-child, and strengthen, Bough over bough, a murmurous pile, And, as your stately stem shall lengthen, So may the statelier of Argyll!
A man plants a tree and questions if that one act fulfills his duty in life. Lowell's response is affirmative: even after the planter has passed away and is forgotten, the tree continues to provide shade, shelter, and a home for travelers, animals, and birds. The poem concludes with a heartfelt wish for both the tree and the Duke of Argyll — on whose estate at Inveraray it was planted — to grow tall and strong.
Line-by-line
Who does his duty is a question / Too complex to be solved by me,
For after he is dead and buried, / And epitaphed, and well forgot,
His deed, its author long outliving, / By Nature's mother-care increased,
The wayfarer, at noon reposing, / Shall bless its shadow on the grass,
The owl, belated in his plundering, / Shall here await the friendly night,
Hither the busy birds shall flutter, / With the light timber for their nests,
What though his memory shall have vanished, / Since the good deed he did survives?
Grow, then, my foster-child, and strengthen, / Bough over bough, a murmurous pile,
Tone & mood
Lowell has a warm and gently humorous style, mixed with a touch of quiet philosophy. He never comes across as preachy; instead, he lightens any serious moment with a comic remark, like the Charon joke or the grumpy owl. The overall impression is of a man in a good mood, engaging in small acts of kindness, and finding that a perfectly satisfying reason to be alive.
Symbols & metaphors
- The tree — The tree symbolizes legacy — a good deed that continues to yield benefits long after the doer is gone. It represents the notion that making anonymous, enduring contributions can achieve a kind of immortality.
- Charon and the ferry — The Greek mythological ferryman who transports souls to the underworld symbolizes a casual approach to death. Lowell employs this figure to recognize mortality while keeping the poem's tone light and cheerful.
- The verdant almoner — An almoner was an official responsible for distributing charity. Referring to the tree as a 'verdant almoner' presents nature's generosity as a continuous, organized gift — the planter's influence remains active in the world.
- The owl — The comic, light-hating owl embodies the wild, unsentimental life that will call the tree home. It serves as a reminder that the tree offers tangible benefits, not merely poetic ones — real creatures will rely on it.
- The wayfarer at noon — The weary traveler resting in the shade represents the everyday person — a symbol for all the future individuals whose lives will be subtly enhanced by one person's small, overlooked gesture.
Historical context
James Russell Lowell penned this poem while visiting Inveraray Castle in Scotland, the home of the Dukes of Argyll. As a notable American poet, critic, and diplomat—serving as U.S. Minister to Britain from 1880 to 1885—Lowell was well-connected in British aristocratic and literary circles. This poem is part of a long-standing tradition of 'occasional verse,' which is written to commemorate specific events or gestures. During the 1880s, when the notion of civic duty and lasting public contribution was a significant cultural focus on both sides of the Atlantic, Lowell was writing. The poem also reflects the 19th-century Romantic and post-Romantic appreciation for nature as a moral guide, yet Lowell's subtle approach prevents it from feeling preachy. The final compliment to the Duke of Argyll serves as a customary touch in occasional poems directed at a host.
FAQ
The poem suggests that planting a tree—a simple, unassuming action—fulfills your duty by generating lasting benefits for others long after you're gone. You don’t have to be remembered to make an impact.
The poem was crafted at Inveraray Castle in Scotland, the residence of the Dukes of Argyll. The last couplet offers a courteous nod to Lowell's host, expressing a hope that the duke will rise in stature as the tree grows taller. This was a typical courtesy found in occasional poems from that time.
An almoner was someone responsible for distributing charity or alms for a wealthy household. Referring to the tree as a 'verdant almoner' (with 'verdant' meaning green) suggests that the tree serves as the representative of the deceased planter, continuing to offer gifts — like shade, shelter, and nesting material — to those in need.
In Greek mythology, Charon is the ferryman who transports the souls of the deceased across the river Styx to the underworld. Lowell uses him humorously to imply 'after the planter has died and moved on to the afterlife'—this lightens the mood and prevents the poem from becoming too somber.
Each stanza consists of a quatrain (four lines) that follows an ABAB rhyme scheme. The meter is mostly iambic tetrameter—four beats per line—but Lowell varies it in a way that keeps it from sounding mechanical. This steady, lively rhythm lends the poem a conversational and lighthearted quality.
In a subtle way, yes. Lowell suggests that you can attain a form of immortality not by seeking fame or building monuments, but through actions that continue to have a positive impact. The planter may be forgotten, yet his influence lives on in the lives of travelers, animals, and birds.
Earlier in the poem, he refers to Nature as the tree's 'mother.' When Lowell speaks to the sapling as his foster-child, he's positioning himself as a secondary parent — the one who initiated the tree's life but is ready to entrust it to Nature's nurturing. This adds a gentle, personal warmth to the ending.
It is an occasional poem, created for a specific event—in this case, the planting of a tree at a particular estate. It isn’t a sonnet; instead, it consists of eight quatrain stanzas. Occasional poems were quite popular in the 19th century, particularly among poets like Lowell who engaged in social and diplomatic circles.