Earth gets its price, etc.: Notice the special meaning given to
_Earth_ here, in contrast with _heaven_ in line 29. Here again the
thought is suggested by Wordsworth's _Ode_, sixth strophe:
"Earth fills our lap with pleasures of her own."
The Annotated Edition
Earth gets its price, etc.: Notice the special meaning given to by James Russell Lowell
Read aloud in ~1 minOpen reading mode →
This is a concise scholarly annotation by James Russell Lowell, not a standalone poem.
- Themes
- memory, mortality, nature
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
This is a concise scholarly annotation by James Russell Lowell, not a standalone poem. It clarifies the term "Earth" as used in a larger work, contrasting it with "heaven" and linking the concept to Wordsworth's *Ode: Intimations of Immortality*. Lowell highlights that the poet he is discussing employed "Earth" in a particular, meaningful context: representing the world of everyday joys and struggles, as opposed to a spiritual or ideal realm. You can think of this as a footnote that sheds light on how poets influence and expand upon each other's thoughts.
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
Earth gets its price, etc.: Notice the special meaning given to
Editor's note
Lowell highlights the word *Earth* as having significant meaning. In the poem he is annotating, 'Earth' refers not only to the physical ground but also to the mortal, material world that requires sacrifices from anyone who inhabits it. The 'etc.' indicates that readers should refer back to the original lines being discussed.
Earth here, in contrast with heaven in line 29.
Editor's note
The contrast between *Earth* and *heaven* lies at the heart of the annotation. Earth symbolizes a place of compromise, pleasure, and the costs that come with them, while heaven signifies an ideal or spiritual state that transcends these exchanges. Lowell aims for readers to sense the tension between the two terms instead of viewing them as mere geographical locations.
Here again the thought is suggested by Wordsworth's Ode, sixth strophe:
Editor's note
Lowell is engaging in a fundamental practice of literary criticism: tracing a lineage. He points to Wordsworth's *Ode: Intimations of Immortality* as the origin of the concept, particularly the sixth strophe. This isn't about accusing anyone of plagiarism; rather, it's an acknowledgment that poets operate within a tradition, intentionally echoing and reinterpreting the images that have preceded them.
"Earth fills our lap with pleasures of her own."
Editor's note
The quoted line from Wordsworth gives Earth a personality, depicting her as a generous figure who compensates us with her pleasures because we've lost something more profound (like the visionary gleam of childhood in Wordsworth's view). Lowell uses this to illustrate that the poet he is discussing inherited and expanded on the same concept of Earth as a comforting, yet inferior, replacement for heaven.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
The tone is precise and collegial, reflecting the voice of a knowledgeable scholar engaging with an equally curious reader. There's no flashiness here, just a steady assurance that the link to Wordsworth is important and that highlighting it will truly enhance the reader's understanding of the poem.
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- Earth
- The mortal, material world—a space filled with genuine pleasures but also significant costs, contrasting sharply with the ideal realm of heaven. Lowell emphasizes that this term serves two purposes: it refers to both the literal ground and a philosophical state.
- Heaven
- The ideal or spiritual state that Earth is compared to. It symbolizes what has been lost or set aside, causing Earth's pleasures to seem more like consolation prizes instead of genuine gifts.
- Lap (Wordsworth's image)
- A comforting, nurturing image — Earth as a mother figure providing whatever comfort she can. The lap implies abundance but also passivity; you get what is offered instead of striving for something greater.
§06Historical context
Historical context
James Russell Lowell (1819–1891) was a leading figure in American literature during the nineteenth century, known for his roles as a poet, critic, editor of *The Atlantic Monthly*, and professor at Harvard. This annotation likely comes from his commentary on a poem, probably his own *The Vision of Sir Launfal* or one he was editing, demonstrating his strong connection to the English Romantic tradition. Wordsworth's *Ode: Intimations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood* (1807) was a key text for Lowell's contemporaries, arguing that we exchange a transcendent childhood vision for the mundane rewards of adult life. This idea influenced many Victorian and post-Romantic poets' views on the connection between the earthly and the ideal. Lowell's note serves as a small act of literary archaeology, pinpointing the source of a particular image for readers.
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
The annotation probably refers to Lowell's poem *The Vision of Sir Launfal* (1848), which includes the line 'Earth gets its price for what Earth gives us.' Lowell created scholarly notes for his own work, and this explanation fits seamlessly into that context.
Lowell illustrates that the concept of Earth as a realm of compensatory pleasures—good things, yet inferior to what we once experienced—originates from Wordsworth's *Ode: Intimations of Immortality*. By highlighting this source, he pays homage to the tradition and enables readers to grasp the depth of the image.
The *Ode: Intimations of Immortality* suggests that children see the world with a special, almost divine light or 'visionary gleam' that diminishes as they become adults. In response, Earth attempts to make up for this loss by offering us her own pleasures — yet these pleasures serve as a stand-in, rather than the genuine experience we once had.
It means that everything you gain from the material world comes with a price. You pay for earthly pleasures — with your time, through compromises, and often by sacrificing something more ideal. In essence, it suggests that life in the physical world is always about transactions.
Earth is where we experience everyday life: joys, expenses, trade-offs, and the reality of death. In contrast, Heaven represents an ideal state — spiritual, flawless, and separate from any transactional nature. This contrast creates a tension that permeates much of Romantic poetry, reflecting the feeling that we inhabit a fallen or lesser world compared to a higher potential.
It’s a scholarly annotation — basically a footnote or endnote that Lowell wrote to clarify his poetic language. It feels like a note a professor would scribble in the margin of a text, directing you to a source and explaining the significance of a specific word.
In the nineteenth century, poets often included explanatory notes with their work, particularly for lengthy poems or those deeply rooted in literary tradition. Lowell aimed for readers to notice the echo of Wordsworth and grasp the philosophical significance of the word 'Earth'—without the note, many readers might have overlooked it entirely.
A strophe is just a section or stanza of a poem. In Wordsworth's *Ode*, the poem is divided into numbered strophes, with the sixth one personifying Earth as she fills our laps with her own pleasures after we've lost the transcendent gleam of childhood. Lowell provides readers with a clear reference so they can check it out themselves.
Read next