The Annotated Edition
CHORUS OF PRIESTS, ACCOMPANIED BY THE COURT PORKMAN ON MARROW-BONES by Percy Bysshe Shelley
A group of priests and court officials chant a hymn of praise to "Famine" — a goddess they've created to explain why the rich continue to thrive while the poor suffer.
- Themes
- anger, identity, justice
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
AND CLEAVERS: / GODDESS bare, and gaunt, and pale,
Editor's note
The stage direction reveals that the chorus is joined by a court butcher clashing marrow-bones and cleavers — a genuine street-music tradition in Georgian England, often performed to mock or celebrate. Presenting Famine as a goddess who is "bare, and gaunt, and pale" instantly gives her the appearance of the starving poor she embodies, rather than a glorious deity. The irony is evident right from the first line.
What though Cretans old called thee / City-crested Cybele?
Editor's note
Cybele was the ancient mother-goddess of Phrygia, frequently depicted with a crown of city towers, symbolizing abundance and civilization. The priests dismiss her with a wave: they’re not interested in old tales of prosperity, so they've renamed her Famine. It’s a biting commentary on how those in power reshape narratives to fit their agendas.
Goddess of fasts and feasts, starving and cramming!
Editor's note
The contrast between fasts and feasts, starving and cramming, sums up the satirical argument perfectly in just one line. The same goddess oversees both, highlighting how the same economic system creates luxury for some while others face starvation. The exclamation mark adds a cheerful tone, which only intensifies the underlying horror.
Through thee, for emperors, kings, and priests and lords, / Who rule by viziers, sceptres, bank-notes, words,
Editor's note
Shelley outlines all the instruments of power: military force (viziers), royal authority (sceptres), financial control (bank-notes), and propaganda (words). This list is intentionally comprehensive—no ruling mechanism escapes scrutiny. He argues that all of them rely on Famine to maintain a desperate and obedient population.
The earth pours forth its plenteous fruits, / Corn, wool, linen, flesh, and roots—
Editor's note
The earth is genuinely productive — there is plenty available. Shelley is highlighting a political-economic argument that scarcity is created, not inherent. The list of goods (corn, wool, linen, flesh, roots) sounds like a harvest song, which makes the following two lines hit even harder.
Those who consume these fruits through thee grow fat, / Those who produce these fruits through thee grow lean,
Editor's note
This is the poem's moral core, expressed with a stark and almost mathematical clarity. Producers go hungry while consumers feast. The parallel structure — "those who consume" / "those who produce" — highlights the injustice in a way that's hard to ignore. Shelley keeps it straightforward.
Whatever change takes place, oh, stick to that! / And let things be as they have ever been;
Editor's note
The priests pray for stasis. No matter how the world shifts, they want to keep the fundamental inequality intact. "Let things be as they have always been" perfectly mocks conservative ideology: tradition disguising self-interest. At least the priests are upfront about their motives, making them both amusing and condemnable.
At least while we remain thy priests, / And proclaim thy fasts and feasts.
Editor's note
The phrase "at least while we remain thy priests" serves as the satirical punchline. Their worship of Famine depends entirely on their own comfort. They aren't genuine believers; instead, they're cynical manipulators who leverage religion and ceremony to safeguard their status.
Through thee the sacred SWELLFOOT dynasty / Is based upon a rock amid that sea / Whose waves are Swine—so let it ever be!
Editor's note
"Swellfoot" refers to George IV, a figure often ridiculed for his obesity. The "sea of Swine" represents the British population, dehumanized by poverty and oppression—reminiscent of Circe's pigs in the *Odyssey*. The ruling dynasty remains perched on its rock above the swine-sea, unscathed. The final phrase, "so let it ever be!" echoes a liturgical response, giving the entire chorus the tone of a corrupt church service.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- Famine as goddess
- By elevating Famine to the level of a deity, Shelley highlights how the ruling class's ideology obscures economic exploitation. Labeling starvation as sacred makes it appear natural and unavoidable instead of stemming from intentional political decisions.
- Cybele / city-crested crown
- The ancient goddess of abundance has been replaced by Famine, showing how civilization has turned its purpose upside down. Cities and states, which were meant to support people, now focus on taking from them.
- The sea of Swine
- The phrase "common people reduced to pigs" refers to Circe's enchantment in Homer's tale. It highlights how poverty and oppression can strip away humanity, reflecting the ruling class's disdain for those under their control.
- The rock
- The Swellfoot dynasty rests on a rock overlooking the swine-sea, giving an illusion of permanence and stability. This imagery reflects the biblical idea of building on rock, but in this case, the foundation is rooted in exploitation rather than virtue.
- Marrow-bones and cleavers
- A genuine Georgian street custom involved butchers making raucous music using bones and cleavers, often poking fun at disliked figures. Shelley employs this tradition right from the beginning to indicate that the work is street satire rather than noble commendation.
- Fasts and feasts
- The two sides of the same corrupt system. Fasting is meant for the poor, while feasting is reserved for the rich. The priests oversee both, highlighting how religion and ceremony are employed to legitimize inequality.
§06Historical context
Historical context
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
Read next