Skip to content
Storgy

The Annotated Edition

BROTHER AND SISTER by D. H. Lawrence

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

Read aloud in ~3 minOpen reading mode →

A brother and sister are mourning the loss of their mother, and Lawrence uses the image of the moon fading in the night sky to illustrate how grief leaves you exposed and pushes you to continue on.

Poet
D. H. Lawrence
Themes
death, growing-up, memory
The PoemFull text

BROTHER AND SISTER

D. H. Lawrence

THE shorn moon trembling indistinct on her path, Frail as a scar upon the pale blue sky, Draws towards the downward slope; some sorrow hath Worn her down to the quick, so she faintly fares Along her foot-searched way without knowing why She creeps persistent down the sky's long stairs. Some say they see, though I have never seen, The dead moon heaped within the new moon's arms; For surely the fragile, fine young thing had been Too heavily burdened to mount the heavens so. But my heart stands still, as a new, strong dread alarms Me; might a young girl be heaped with such shadow of woe? Since Death from the mother moon has pared us down to the quick, And cast us forth like shorn, thin moons, to travel An uncharted way among the myriad thick Strewn stars of silent people, and luminous litter Of lives which sorrows like mischievous dark mice chavel To nought, diminishing each star's glitter, Since Death has delivered us utterly, naked and white, Since the month of childhood is over, and we stand alone, Since the beloved, faded moon that set us alight Is delivered from us and pays no heed though we moan In sorrow, since we stand in bewilderment, strange And fearful to sally forth down the sky's long range. We may not cry to her still to sustain us here, We may not hold her shadow back from the dark. Oh, let us here forget, let us take the sheer Unknown that lies before us, bearing the ark Of the covenant onwards where she cannot go. Let us rise and leave her now, she will never know.

Public domain

Sourced from Project Gutenberg

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

A brother and sister are mourning the loss of their mother, and Lawrence uses the image of the moon fading in the night sky to illustrate how grief leaves you exposed and pushes you to continue on. The poem follows their path from shock and sadness to the tough choice of letting go and stepping into an uncertain future. It explores how losing a parent severs the ties to childhood and thrusts you into a sudden, daunting sense of freedom.

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

  1. THE shorn moon trembling indistinct on her path, / Frail as a scar upon the pale blue sky,

    Editor's note

    Lawrence begins with the moon depicted as a wounded, frail figure — "shorn" and "frail as a scar." It moves aimlessly, burdened by an unspoken grief. This serves as the poem's core image: the dying moon representing the dying mother, fading yet still following its steady course across the sky.

  2. Some say they see, though I have never seen, / The dead moon heaped within the new moon's arms;

    Editor's note

    There's a folk belief that you can glimpse the old, dark moon nestled within the thin crescent of the new one. Lawrence admits he's never spotted it, but the thought scares him — it brings to mind a young girl (his sister) being overwhelmed by grief and loss. This fear is both personal and immediate: it jumps from the stars to family in an instant.

  3. Since Death from the mother moon has pared us down to the quick, / And cast us forth like shorn, thin moons, to travel

    Editor's note

    Now the metaphor makes sense. The mother is the "mother moon," and her death has left the siblings feeling empty — "pared to the quick" means cut down to the raw flesh. They are cast out like new moons, thin and barely visible, drifting through a sky filled with the lives of others, all of which are also being quietly eroded by sorrow.

  4. Since Death has delivered us utterly, naked and white, / Since the month of childhood is over, and we stand alone,

    Editor's note

    This stanza is a lengthy string of "since" — a growing list of losses. Childhood has ended. The mother is no longer there to watch over them. They are "naked and white," vulnerable and defenseless. The term "delivered" holds two meanings: death has presented them to the world, much like a birth brings forth a child, but in this context, it feels more like abandonment than a welcoming arrival.

  5. We may not cry to her still to sustain us here, / We may not hold her shadow back from the dark.

    Editor's note

    The final stanza shifts from sorrow to determination. They can't bring the mother back; they can't halt her departure. So, Lawrence decides to embrace the "sheer unknown" ahead, to honor the promise of their shared life, and to move on. The expression "bearing the ark of the covenant" elevates this act of moving forward into something nearly sacred — a responsibility, not a betrayal. The last line, "she will never know," carries both a sense of heartbreak and liberation.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

The tone begins mournful and quiet — reminiscent of someone softly speaking in a dark room — before gradually becoming more resolute. There’s genuine tenderness, particularly toward the sister, but Lawrence avoids letting the poem slip into self-pity. By the end, while the grief remains, the voice has found a sense of solemn courage.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

The shorn moon
The fading moon is like a mother—worn by illness or age, yet still following her path as she diminishes. "Shorn" implies that something has been taken from her, and this word resonates throughout the poem, reflecting the siblings as well.
The new moon cradling the old
The folk image of the dead moon cradled in the new moon's arms symbolizes the fear that grief might engulf the young and living—especially the worry that the sister could be crushed by the weight of their mother's death.
The ark of the covenant
The ark, taken from the Hebrew Bible, represents the sacred container that a people in exile once bore. In this context, it symbolizes all that the siblings bring from their shared history — memory, love, and identity — as they step into a new life without their mother.
Stars as other people's lives
The "myriad thick strewn stars of silent people" transforms the night sky into a gathering of strangers, each leading their own life, each quietly weighed down by sorrow. This imagery makes grief seem like a shared experience instead of a solitary one.
The sky's long stairs / range
The sky is a path we must walk — downward for the dying moon, forward for the living siblings. It portrays life after loss as a journey without a map, which is precisely how Lawrence puts it: "an uncharted way."

§06Historical context

Historical context

Lawrence wrote this poem in the years around the death of his mother Lydia in December 1910, a moment that profoundly impacted his life. He was incredibly close to her, and losing her to cancer left him shattered. He confided to friends that he felt like half of himself had died with her. His early poetry collection *Amores* (1916) is filled with poems exploring this grief, and "Brother and Sister" fits squarely within that theme. The poem also highlights the genuine connection between Lawrence and his sister Ada, who cared for their mother during her final illness. Lawrence uses the moon as a maternal symbol, drawing from a long tradition, but he personalizes it so deeply that the celestial and the domestic intertwine in a uniquely intimate way.

§07FAQ

Questions readers ask

It's about Lawrence and his sister Ada coping with the loss of their mother, Lydia Lawrence, who passed away from cancer in 1910. The moon in the poem symbolizes their mother — diminishing, weary, and ultimately absent.

Read next

Poems in the same key

Similar poems

Requiem — Robert Louis StevensonDo Not Go Gentle into That Good Night — Dylan ThomasCrossing the Bar — Alfred, Lord TennysonThe Darkling Thrush — Thomas Hardy

More by D. H. Lawrence

Browse all D. H. Lawrence poems →

Themes in this poem

Poems about deathPoems about growing-upPoems about memoryPoems about sorrow