Skip to content
Storgy

The Annotated Edition

Thomas by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

Read aloud in ~1 minOpen reading mode →

This short poem expresses the thoughts of the apostle Thomas right after the Resurrection, illustrating his blend of faith and deep disappointment.

Core theme
Doubt
The PoemFull text

Thomas

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

And I have seen Him. I have seen the print Of nails upon his hands, and thrust my hands Into his side. I know He is arisen; But where are now the kingdom and the glory He promised unto us? We have all dreamed That we were princes, and we wake to find We are but fishermen.

Public domain

Sourced from Project Gutenberg

Study actions

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

This short poem expresses the thoughts of the apostle Thomas right after the Resurrection, illustrating his blend of faith and deep disappointment. Thomas has witnessed the risen Christ firsthand—he's even touched the wounds—but he still feels let down because the glorious kingdom Jesus spoke of hasn't come to pass. It reflects the struggle of having faith reaffirmed while still grappling with shattered hopes.

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

  1. And I have seen Him. I have seen the print / Of nails upon his hands, and thrust my hands

    Editor's note

    Longfellow begins in the middle of a thought, as if Thomas is either talking to himself or to an unseen listener. The repeated phrase "I have seen" emphasizes that Thomas is *not* expressing doubt — this is the same man who famously sought proof and received it. The vivid details of the nail marks and the wound in the side come directly from the Gospel of John (chapter 20). By starting with the physical body, Longfellow grounds the poem in tangible reality before transitioning to the spiritual struggle.

  2. Into his side. I know He is arisen; / But where are now the kingdom and the glory

    Editor's note

    The semicolon after "arisen" acts as the poem's pivot point. Thomas fully acknowledges the miracle—there's no doubt about it—but then he swiftly turns to grief with the word "But." The phrase "kingdom and the glory" reflects the language of Jewish messianic hope: a tangible reign of justice and power on Earth. Thomas was convinced that Jesus would bring this about, yet the Resurrection, as miraculous as it may be, hasn’t achieved that vision.

  3. He promised unto us? We have all dreamed / That we were princes, and we wake to find

    Editor's note

    The question mark feels like a subtle accusation. Thomas voices what all the disciples are feeling — "we have all dreamed" — expanding the poem from an individual crisis to a shared human experience of unmet expectations. The dream-of-princes imagery is striking: these men abandoned their nets with the hope of one day sitting on thrones to judge the twelve tribes of Israel (Matthew 19:28). That promise lingers in the air, still unfulfilled.

  4. We are but fishermen.

    Editor's note

    The final line hits hard with its simplicity. After all the deep themes of resurrection and kingdom, Longfellow settles on the most everyday word: *fishermen*. There's no glory, no throne, no changed world — just guys who smell like fish and have patched-up nets. The word "but" carries a lot of weight here, conveying both humility and a sense of loss. The poem closes without a tidy ending, which is the point: faith and disappointment can exist side by side.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

The tone reflects a quiet anguish — not an explosion of rage or a complete despair, but rather a profound, lingering grief. Thomas speaks in a flat, exhausted voice, as if he's achieved exactly what he wanted yet still feels disappointed. There's a sense of dignity in his words; he isn't rejecting his faith, just grieving the space between what was promised and what actually is. Longfellow uses simple, straightforward language, which amplifies the emotional impact.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

The nail-prints and the wound in the side
These serve as physical proof of the Resurrection, yet in this poem, they act as evidence that doesn't alter Thomas's earthly reality. They affirm the miracle while highlighting just how little it has changed for him in practical terms.
The kingdom and the glory
This phrase embodies a deep messianic hope — a changed world, justice, strength, and liberation from Roman rule. Its omission in the poem causes Thomas's sorrow. The words resonate with liturgical language ("thine is the kingdom, the power, and the glory"), making their lack of fulfillment feel even more significant.
The dream of being princes
Dreams in this context symbolize the disciples' initial aspirations for success and meaning in the world. Awakening from that dream serves as a metaphor for the disappointment that can arise even after a true miracle, especially when that miracle fails to alter the course of everyday life.
Fishermen
Fishing was the real trade of some of the disciples, including Thomas's companions. Here, it symbolizes the ordinary, the humble, and the familiar rhythm of daily life — contrasting sharply with the grand destiny they thought they were meant to fulfill.

§06Form & structure

Form & structure

Meter
blank verse

§07Historical context

Historical context

Longfellow published a series of dramatic monologues titled *Christus: A Mystery* in 1872, which he developed over nearly thirty years. *Thomas* is featured in the section named *The Divine Tragedy*, where scenes from the Gospels are dramatized through the voices of biblical characters. Longfellow wrote this work following significant personal tragedy—his second wife had perished in a fire in 1861. His later religious poetry often reflects a struggle between genuine faith and the sense that God's promises have fallen short. The poem is based on John 20:24–29, which depicts the well-known "Doubting Thomas" story, but Longfellow's Thomas has transcended doubt, arriving at a more complex state: belief without comfort. The dramatic monologue form, made popular by Tennyson and Browning during this time, allows Longfellow to give a biblical figure a deeply personal and psychologically nuanced voice.

§08FAQ

Questions readers ask

Is this the same Thomas as 'Doubting Thomas' from the Bible?

Yes, that's right. The poem continues right after the Gospel of John ends — when Thomas has touched the wounds and expressed his belief. Longfellow's unique take is that he reveals what happens after doubt is settled, showing that belief alone doesn't address the underlying disappointment.

Why does Thomas sound so sad if he knows Jesus rose from the dead?

The Resurrection didn't provide the disciples with what they had anticipated: a tangible kingdom, freedom from Roman rule, and positions of power for the twelve apostles. Thomas is convinced that the miracle occurred, but the expected outcomes of that miracle — a changed world — are still missing. This disconnect between his solid faith and his unfulfilled hopes is the true focus of the poem.

What does 'we are but fishermen' mean?

It highlights that despite everything—the miracles, the teachings, the Resurrection—these men remain ordinary working folks. Several disciples, like Peter and Andrew, were fishermen before they chose to follow Jesus. Longfellow uses this term to convey how little their lives seem in comparison to the grand promises they received.

Is this poem a sonnet or does it have a specific form?

No, it's written in blank verse — unrhymed iambic pentameter. This is the same meter used in Shakespeare's plays and Milton's Paradise Lost. The absence of rhyme allows it to flow like natural speech rather than a formal hymn, which fits well with the raw, personal nature of Thomas's confession.

What is the 'kingdom and the glory' Thomas mentions?

This refers to the messianic kingdom that Jewish tradition and Jesus's teachings led the disciples to anticipate: a genuine reign of God on earth, characterized by justice, power, and the restoration of Israel. The phrase also resonates with the doxology at the end of the Lord's Prayer ("thine is the kingdom, the power, and the glory"), so a reader familiar with Christian liturgy would likely sense the irony of those words appearing in a lament.

Where does this poem come from? Is it a standalone piece?

It's part of Longfellow's expansive dramatic trilogy Christus: A Mystery (1872), particularly the section titled The Divine Tragedy. This part dramatizes Jesus' life through a collection of monologues and scenes delivered by biblical figures. Thomas stands out as one of the shorter and more focused pieces in that collection.

Does Longfellow agree with Thomas, or is he criticizing him?

Longfellow is entirely sympathetic toward Thomas, offering him a voice filled with understanding. Considering Longfellow's own struggles with grief and faith following his wife's death, it's difficult not to see reflections of his own emotions in Thomas's words. The poem presents the divide between faith and fulfillment as a genuine human experience rather than a spiritual shortcoming.

What makes this poem different from a typical religious poem of the 1800s?

Most Victorian religious poetry tends to celebrate faith or depict the struggle to attain it. This poem takes a different approach: it presents a believer whose faith remains strong, yet whose hope has been hurt. Thomas isn't questioning God's power — he's mourning the gap between the miraculous and everyday life. That psychological depth feels surprisingly contemporary for its time.

Citation

Cite this poem

MLA

Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth. "Thomas." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/thomas-henry-wadsworth-longfellow/.

APA

Longfellow, H. W. (n.d.). Thomas. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/thomas-henry-wadsworth-longfellow/

The study desk

Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.

Adjacent texts in the archive