The Annotated Edition

The Collar by George Herbert

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

A man is angry about the limitations of his religious life and yells that he's had enough — he craves freedom, pleasure, and a life unbound by rules.

Poet: George Herbert
Core theme: Doubt

The PoemFull text

The Collar

George Herbert

I struck the board, and cry'd, No more; I will abroad. What? shall I ever sigh and pine? My lines and life are free; free as the rode, Loose as the winde, as large as store. Shall I be still in suit? Have I no harvest but a thorn To let me bloud, and not restore What I have lost with cordiall fruit? Sure there was wine Before my sighs did drie it: there was corn Before my tears did drown it. Is the yeare onely lost to me? Have I no bayes to crown it? No flowers, no garlands gay? all blasted? All wasted? Not so, my heart: but there is fruit, And thou hast hands. Recover all thy sigh-blown age On double pleasures: leave thy cold dispute Of what is fit, and not. Forsake thy cage, Thy rope of sands, Which pettie thoughts have made, and made to thee Good cable, to enforce and draw, And be thy law, While thou didst wink and wouldst not see. Away; take heed, I will abroad. Call in thy deaths head there: tie up thy fears. He that forbears To suit and serve his need, Deserves his load. But as I rav'd and grew more fierce and wilde At every word, Me thoughts I heard one calling, Childe: And I reply'd, My Lord.

Study actions

Study sheet (PDF)

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

A man is angry about the limitations of his religious life and yells that he's had enough — he craves freedom, pleasure, and a life unbound by rules. He works himself into a frenzy, enumerating all that he believes he's been deprived of. Then, just as it all seems to peak, he hears God call him "Child," and that fury melts away into two soft words: "My Lord."

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

I struck the board, and cry'd, No more; / I will abroad.
Editor's note
The speaker slams his hand on the table—a clear act of rebellion—and announces he's leaving. "Abroad" signifies stepping out into the world, escaping the restrictive life of religious devotion. Herbert plunges us right into a tantrum that's already underway, which is a daring way to start.
What? shall I ever sigh and pine? / My lines and life are free; free as the rode,
Editor's note
He wonders: why am I wasting my life in grief and longing? He claims his life *is* free — "free as the road, loose as the wind" — but the need to insist on this suggests he doesn't fully believe it. "Lines" refers to both the lines of his poetry and the lines of his fate.
Have I no harvest but a thorn / To let me bloud, and not restore
Editor's note
The thorn draws blood but offers nothing in return — it evokes Christ's crown of thorns and represents a life of sacrifice that seems unrewarded. He's questioning: is this all I get for my suffering? The harvest metaphor flows through this section, highlighting what he's sacrificed (wine, corn, fruit) against what he's actually received.
Sure there was wine / Before my sighs did drie it: there was corn
Editor's note
He remembers—or maybe imagines—a life filled with abundance before his religious devotion drained it away. Wine and corn both symbolize the Eucharist, adding a layer of irony to his complaint: the very things his faith promises (bread and wine) are the same things he feels have been taken from him by that faith.
Is the yeare onely lost to me? / Have I no bayes to crown it?
Editor's note
"Bayes" refers to laurel leaves — the traditional symbol of poetic success and earthly fame. He wonders if he’ll receive no acknowledgment, no garlands, and nothing to mark his years. "All blasted? All wasted?" These quick, sharp questions capture the intensity of someone spiraling into anger.
Not so, my heart: but there is fruit, / And thou hast hands.
Editor's note
A pivot — he begins convincing himself to take action. There *is* fruit out there, and his hands are ready to reach for it. This is the voice of temptation or self-justification, pushing him to stop waiting and seize what the world has to offer.
Recover all thy sigh-blown age / On double pleasures: leave thy cold dispute
Editor's note
He reminds himself to compensate for lost time by seeking double the pleasure. "Cold dispute / Of what is fit, and not" reflects his rejection of moral reasoning — he urges to stop debating right and wrong and just live. The word "cold" carries significant weight here: he portrays religious conscience as joyless and devoid of passion.
Forsake thy cage, / Thy rope of sands,
Editor's note
"Rope of sands" is a striking image: a rope made of sand lacks real strength, yet it has managed to hold him. He claims his religious obligations are merely an illusion of constraint — they bind him only because he allows them to. The cage is of his own making.
Which pettie thoughts have made, and made to thee / Good cable, to enforce and draw,
Editor's note
Small, timid thoughts have transformed a fragile rope of sand into something that feels like a ship's cable — heavy, binding, inescapable. The difference between "petty" and "good cable" illustrates how the mind magnifies its own limitations.
Away; take heed, / I will abroad.
Editor's note
The phrase "I will abroad" resonates with the opening, but it now comes across as more desperate than defiant. The repetition hints at his attempt to persuade himself. "Take heed" feels like a strange interjection — heed of what, exactly? It resembles a man yelling to drown out a quieter voice within.
Call in thy deaths head there: tie up thy fears. / He that forbears
Editor's note
"Deaths head" refers to a skull — a memento mori, serving as a reminder of our mortality often used in religious reflection. He's urging himself to set that symbol aside, to stop allowing the fear of death and judgment to control him. "He that forbears / To suit and serve his need, / Deserves his load" is a practical saying: if you neglect your own well-being, you should expect to face the consequences.
But as I rav'd and grew more fierce and wilde / At every word,
Editor's note
The narrator takes a moment to reflect on the events unfolding: raving, becoming increasingly chaotic. Throughout the poem, the rebellion has been intensifying, and now Herbert calls it out directly. The term "rav'd" carries weight — it casts everything we've just read in a light of madness.
Me thoughts I heard one calling, Childe: / And I reply'd, My Lord.
Editor's note
The whole storm wraps up in four words. God calls him "Child" — not out of anger, but with the calm authority of a parent gently calling a wandering child. The speaker's reaction is immediate and complete. All the arguments, the rage, the need to justify himself: vanished. Herbert suggests that the relationship was never truly at risk — it just needed a tantrum to bring that back to mind.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

The tone throughout the poem is volcanic—furious, impatient, and self-righteous—before shifting to something almost tender in the last two lines. Herbert earns that quiet conclusion by first making the preceding noise genuinely loud. The speaker doesn't just perform rebellion; he sounds like a man who truly means it, right up until he doesn't.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

The collar: The title features a central image, even though the word itself doesn’t show up in the poem. A collar can refer to a clerical collar (a symbol of a priest's calling), a yoke used on animals, or a form of restraint. It also plays on the word "choler," which is an old term for anger, one of the four humors. Thus, the title captures themes of vocation, constraint, and rage simultaneously.
The thorn: A clear reflection of Christ's crown of thorns, symbolizing sacrifice and suffering. The speaker feels bitterness towards it because it inflicts pain without offering anything in return — he seeks a harvest, not a wound.
Wine and corn: On the surface, there’s worldly abundance — the good life he feels he’s missed out on. But wine and bread (corn) are also key elements of the Eucharist, adding a layer of irony to his complaint: he’s grieving the loss of what his faith is meant to offer.
The rope of sands: A rope made from sand — impossible to create and not practical at all. It symbolizes the religious obligations that the speaker feels are restricting him. The idea is that these obligations only limit him because he believes they do; the restriction is something he has placed on himself.
The board: The table he hits at the start could be a dining table, a communion table, or a writing desk. No matter what it is, hitting it symbolizes rejection—he's distancing himself from the life he's been leading.
The deaths head (skull): A memento mori — a skull used to remind people of their mortality, often seen in 17th-century religious practices. The speaker urges himself to "call it in" and set it aside, dismissing the notion that fear of death should dictate how he lives.

§06Historical context

Historical context

George Herbert was an Anglican priest and a leading figure among the Metaphysical poets, writing in the early 17th century alongside John Donne. He chose to leave a promising career at court, where he had ties to King James I, to take on a small rural parish in Bemerton, Wiltshire, where he served until he died of tuberculosis at the age of 39. His complete poetry collection, *The Temple*, was published posthumously in 1633, the same year he passed away. "The Collar" explores Herbert's recurring theme: the tumultuous and personal relationship between the human soul and God. The Metaphysical poets were noted for using common objects and sharp logical arguments, known as "conceits," to delve into spiritual questions, and Herbert is recognized as one of the finest in this style. The poem's dramatic structure, characterized by a lengthy outburst resolved in a single moment, mirrors the Puritan and Anglican spiritual culture of the time, where grappling with one's faith was seen as both normal and essential.

§07FAQ

Questions readers ask

What does the title 'The Collar' mean?

The word never appears in the poem, and that’s kind of the point. It operates on three levels at the same time: a clerical collar (a sign of a priest's vocation), a yoke or restraint used on an animal, and a play on "choler" — the old English term for anger. All three meanings are at play simultaneously, which is typical of Herbert.

Who is the speaker talking to throughout the poem?

Mostly himself. The long central section features the speaker grappling with his conscience, attempting to convince himself to abandon his religious vows. At the very end, God speaks — just one word, "Childe" — and the speaker replies. The transition from internal monologue to dialogue is what gives the ending its strength.

What does 'rope of sands' mean?

It's an image of something that appears to be a restraint but lacks any real strength — a rope made of sand would disintegrate instantly. The speaker suggests that his religious obligations are similar: they only bind him because he thinks they do. The cage is one he constructed on his own.

Why does the poem end so abruptly?

That's the entire design. Herbert crafts around thirty lines of growing anger and then wraps it up in just four words. The suddenness reflects the experience he's portraying: the moment of grace isn't debated into being; it simply shows up. No amount of clever reasoning can create it — only a single word from God can.

Is Herbert actually rejecting his faith in this poem?

No — and the ending makes that clear. The poem captures a crisis of faith rather than a complete break from it. Herbert openly acknowledges that religious devotion can feel confining, and that feelings of doubt and resentment are genuine. However, the resolution indicates that the bond with God endures through the turmoil and was never truly at risk.

What does 'bayes' mean in line 14?

Laurel leaves — a traditional symbol of poetic success and honor. In ancient Greece and Rome, poets and heroes wore laurel wreaths as a mark of distinction. The speaker wonders if he'll receive any acknowledgment or glory for his years of dedication. Given his current state of mind, the answer appears to be no.

Why does the speaker repeat 'I will abroad'?

Repetition in an argument often suggests that the speaker is trying to convince themselves rather than simply stating a fact. The first instance comes off as a declaration; the second feels like an attempt to shout down any doubts. By the time they repeat it again, you can sense that the rebellion is starting to lose its strength.

What is the poem's structure, and does it mean anything?

The rhyme scheme is intentionally irregular throughout the poem, with lines of different lengths and rhymes that come unexpectedly. This reflects the speaker's chaotic and frantic state of mind. In the last four lines, the structure becomes more orderly and stable. Form and content align: the poem finds its calm as the speaker does.

Citation

Cite this poem

MLA

Herbert, George. "The Collar." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/the-collar-george-herbert/.

APA

Herbert, G. (n.d.). The collar. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/the-collar-george-herbert/

TeacherAP Lit Q1 scaffold — preview

Row A — Thesis

1 pt

In 'The Collar,' George Herbert dramatizes the soul's rebellion against divine service not as a moment of genuine freedom but as a self-exposing performance, one in which the very extravagance of the speaker's defiance reveals how …

Row B — Evidence + Commentary4 pts
Row C — Sophistication1 pt
Common student errors

Unlock the full scaffold

Available on any Storgy plan — model paragraphs, band callouts, and common student errors for every poem.

Adjacent texts in the archive

More by George Herbert

Browse all George Herbert poems →

Themes in this poem

Poems about Doubt Poems about Faith Poems about Freedom Poems about Identity

Compared with

Compare this poem with any other →

Poetry tools

Analyze another poem →Rate your own poem →Check rhyme & meter →

Best Poems About Love

Story Rater

Guides for the books you're assigned

Simple, flat pricing