Skip to content
Storgy

The Annotated Edition

Supple-tempered will: One of the most pronounced traits of by James Russell Lowell

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

This brief verse paints a portrait of Abraham Lincoln as a man of unique balance: kind and approachable on the surface, yet strong and steadfast beneath.

Poet
James Russell Lowell
The PoemFull text

Supple-tempered will: One of the most pronounced traits of

James Russell Lowell

Lincoln's character was his kindly, almost femininely gentle and sympathetic spirit. With this, however, was combined a determination of steel. 175-178. Nothing of Europe here: There was nothing of Europe in him, or, if anything, it was of Europe in her early ages of freedom before there was any distinction of slave and master, groveling Russian Serf and noble Lord or Peer.

Public domain

Sourced from Project Gutenberg

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

This brief verse paints a portrait of Abraham Lincoln as a man of unique balance: kind and approachable on the surface, yet strong and steadfast beneath. Lowell contends that Lincoln's character was distinctly American — grounded in a more liberated spirit that existed before Europe's class divisions. It’s a tribute that suggests Lincoln emerged from a time before kings and serfs, before the idea of anyone being born superior or inferior to another took hold.

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

  1. Lincoln's character was his kindly, almost femininely gentle and sympathetic spirit.

    Editor's note

    Lowell begins by highlighting Lincoln's most notable trait: a warmth and tenderness he refers to as "femininely gentle." This was a daring compliment in the 19th century, as softness in a leader was frequently perceived as a flaw. Lowell challenges that notion — the gentleness is the *first* quality to mention, rather than something to be downplayed or justified.

  2. With this, however, was combined a determination of steel.

    Editor's note

    The pivot is sharp and intentional. That tenderness didn't stand alone—it was combined with unwavering resolve. "Determination of steel" is a classic Lowell touch: straightforward, tangible, and clear. The contrast between softness and steel encapsulates the entire argument of the piece in a nutshell.

  3. Nothing of Europe here: There was nothing of Europe in him,

    Editor's note

    Lowell now zooms out to present a broader perspective on Lincoln's identity. He wasn't influenced by European traditions of hierarchy, deference, or inherited rank. This statement serves as a declaration — a clear break from the Old World and all it represented.

  4. or, if anything, it was of Europe in her early ages of freedom before there was any distinction of slave and master,

    Editor's note

    Lowell carefully qualifies his claim. If Lincoln possessed *any* European quality, it came from a mythic, pre-hierarchical Europe — an era before the structures of class and bondage were established. This allows Lowell to commend Lincoln without entirely dismissing European civilization; he critiques its corruptions, not its foundational ideals.

  5. groveling Russian Serf and noble Lord or Peer.

    Editor's note

    The passage concludes with two opposing figures — the serf and the lord — symbolizing the dual degradations of a class system: one oppressed, one undeservedly elevated. By specifically naming the Russian serf, Lowell highlights the starkest example of European subjugation for his readers. The poem asserts that Lincoln emerged from a world where neither figure was present.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

Lowell writes with conviction, inviting you to see the world through his eyes. There's no hesitation or qualification—just a clear, confident portrayal crafted in strong, straightforward prose-verse. The tone is uplifting without becoming overly sentimental, and his admiration stays grounded, avoiding any hint of idolization.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

Determination of steel
Steel represents Lincoln's steadfast inner resolve, the quality that kept him steady throughout the Civil War. Combining it with "gentle" introduces the core tension of the poem: true strength can coexist with tenderness.
Europe
Europe represents an inherited hierarchy and a rigid class system, reflecting a long history where some are born to rule while others are born to serve. It embodies the Old World in a negative light — everything the American experiment aimed to escape.
The Russian Serf and the Lord
These two figures illustrate a fractured social order — one marked by complete subjugation and the other by unearned privilege. Together, they embody the system that Lincoln's character, and America's founding promise, resisted.
Early ages of freedom
Lowell envisions a pre-feudal Europe as a golden age of equality. This mythical reference point allows him to celebrate Lincoln as someone who restored an ancient sense of human dignity, rather than merely creating an American version.

§06Historical context

Historical context

James Russell Lowell wrote this passage as part of his tribute to Abraham Lincoln, likely penned in the years after Lincoln's assassination in 1865. As one of the prominent literary figures of 19th-century America—a poet, critic, and editor of *The Atlantic Monthly*—Lowell approached his assessment of Lincoln with both scholarly insight and patriotic sentiment. The mention of the "Russian Serf" would have struck a chord with contemporary readers: serfdom in Russia was only abolished in 1861, the same year the American Civil War started, and the comparison between Russian serfs and American slaves was a hot topic in political discussions at the time. Lowell's argument—that Lincoln represented a form of freedom that predated European class systems—sought to anchor American democracy in something more profound than just politics.

§07FAQ

Questions readers ask

He's making a clear point about strength. In the 1800s, calling a powerful man "gentle" could easily come off as an insult. Lowell embraces this idea, arguing that Lincoln's warmth and empathy were *strengths*, not weaknesses. By using the word "femininely," he emphasizes that this gentleness was real and profound — not just a political act.

Read next

Poems in the same key

Similar poems

THE PRESENT CRISIS — James Russell LowellTHE ARSENAL AT SPRINGFIELD — Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

More by James Russell Lowell

Browse all James Russell Lowell poems →

Themes in this poem

Poems about couragePoems about freedomPoems about identityPoems about memory