The Annotated Edition
Eugene Field by Eugene Field
This piece is a lengthy, humorous letter-essay by Eugene Field written during his time in bed with an illness.
- Poet
- Eugene Field
- Core theme
- Childhood
Study actions
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
BUENA PARK, NOVEMBER 15, 1893. / I am still sick abed and I find it hard to think out and write a letter.
Editor's note
Field opens with a dateline and candidly admits that he is unwell and having a tough time writing. The instruction to "read between the lines" establishes the tone for the entire piece: the genuine message is one of warmth and affection, rather than the words on the page. This setup also allows him to meander, dream, and joke — after all, he’s a sick man doing his best.
I have often thought, as I saw him through his later years espousing the noblest causes...
Editor's note
Field reflects on his memories of David Swing, a cherished preacher and freethinker from Chicago. When he shares the story of Swing's death, it leads him to delve into his own complex feelings about religion and preaching. His admission that he feels compelled to "preach some little verses" during Christmas, or else he struggles to endure the season, is significant: it reveals that his humor and moral seriousness stem from the same source, just expressed in different ways.
He had to get on with blood which was exquisitely harmonious with the heart of the Christ.
Editor's note
This section honors Field's character by portraying him as someone who was naturally kind to all living beings. The tale of the ugly bulldog stands out — Field spends fifteen dollars, originally set aside for a bill, to save a plain dog from an unkind owner. This illustrates that Field's compassion was both spontaneous and complete, demonstrating that he prioritized maintaining his creative "tempo" alongside his moral instincts, rather than placing one above the other.
Christianity was increasingly dear to him as the discovery of childhood and the unfolding of its revelations.
Editor's note
Here, Field reflects on his theology, which centers around the innocence of childhood. He believed that embracing goodness meant adopting a child's openness, and his unfinished dream was to write about Jesus' boyhood. The passage describing his Puritan ancestors "living in him" and rebelling after Christmas dinner is both humorous and deeply insightful: he experienced his heritage as a physical, internal debate.
Then, as if he had it in his mind,--poor, pale, yellow-skinned sufferer,-- / to attract one to the book he delighted in...
Editor's note
Field transitions into a dream sequence, crafted in a purposely mock-archaic style that mimics Puritan diary entries and legal records. This dream is filled with real historical details — Judge Sewall's public confession, the armed congregation, the disputes over seating — all presented for comedic effect. The humor lies in the fact that Field, a man who savored Christmas pie with delight, finds himself haunted in his dream by the ghost of his Puritan conscience.
At this, it appears that I groaned in my sleep...
Editor's note
The frame collapses in a charming manner here: Field shares that he was dreaming he was asleep within another dream, and his groan in that inner dream caused him to wake up in the outer dream. The tithing-man — whose literal role was to poke sleeping churchgoers awake with a stick — leads him out, and Field finds himself waking up in the "noone-house" (a warming shelter outside the meetinghouse). This humorous setup lays the groundwork for the poem that follows.
"Mother," says I, "is that a pie?" in tones akin to scorning;
Editor's note
The first stanza of the embedded poem presents a lighthearted domestic scene: the speaker feigns suspicion about the Christmas pie but quickly relents and requests a slice with cheese. The rhythm is lively and reminiscent of music hall merriment, and the punchline revolves around the word "sin" — the grocery store’s ingredients are humorously labeled as "all kinds of sin," perfectly capturing the Puritan perspective that Field has been poking fun at throughout.
But once a year comes Christmas cheer, and one should then be merry,
Editor's note
The second stanza packs a humorous moral punch. Field confesses that the pie is still in his stomach and will remain there until May or June, then earnestly advises the reader to "eschew the vice of eating pie in the morning." The humor lies in the contrast between the lofty, sermon-like tone and the utterly trivial topic. This is the "little sermon" he mentioned he always had to deliver at Christmas — and naturally, it’s about pie.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- The Christmas pie
- The pie is the central comic symbol of the entire piece. It represents earthly pleasure, holiday indulgence, and the body's stubborn refusal to align with the soul's higher aspirations. In the Puritan dream, it brings about guilt and indigestion in equal measure. Field uses it to gently poke fun at both Puritan austerity and his own struggle to resist a delightful temptation.
- The bulldog
- The bulldog that Field buys on impulse for fifteen dollars may not be pretty or charming; in fact, he describes its face as something that "ached" from its own homeliness. Yet, this "ugly" dog symbolizes Field's instinctive and practical compassion. Its lack of conventional beauty is precisely what makes the rescue significant, demonstrating that his kindness isn't dependent on charm or any form of reward.
- The Puritan ancestors
- Field's imagined Puritan ancestors, who "live in him" and rise up after Christmas dinner, symbolize the ongoing struggle between enjoyment and moral duty. Instead of being a source of shame, they provide comedic relief — like internal hecklers navigating the Mayflower within his gut. They also embody the preaching instinct he could never fully escape.
- The child / childhood
- Childhood in this piece isn't just nostalgia; it's a form of theology. Field truly thought that moral renewal meant embracing a child's openness. His unfinished ambition to write about the boyhood of Jesus stands out as the most profound moment in the entire letter. The child represents a self that hasn't yet been hardened by habits and doctrines.
- The tithing-man's staff
- The Puritan church officer who nudges dozing congregants awake with a stick serves as a humorous representation of conscience — an outside force that demands awareness and conformity. His gentle guidance of Field, without the stick, reflects a small kindness that parallels Field's own compassionate approach to the moral shortcomings of others.
§06Historical context
Historical context
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
Is this a poem or an essay? What exactly is it?
It’s both, and that’s the point. The work is a personal letter or essay that culminates in a brief comic poem. Field was a newspaper columnist, and this blend—part anecdote, part dream, part verse—was quintessentially his style. The poem at the end is the "little sermon" he claimed he always needed to share at Christmas.
Who is David Swing, and why does Field spend so much time on him?
David Swing was a well-known preacher in Chicago, recognized for his gentle and unconventional theology. In 1874, he faced a heresy trial but was acquitted, which helped him gain popularity as a public figure. Field had a deep admiration for him, and the tribute presented here is sincere, even with its humorous touches. The anecdote about Swing being too delicate to serve as a special policeman enforcing animal cruelty laws is meant to be affectionate rather than mocking.
What is the "Saints' and Sinners' Corner"?
This was a well-known informal gathering place at McClurg's bookshop in Chicago, where writers, journalists, clergy, and intellectuals came together to chat. Field frequented this spot, making it one of the vibrant literary social hubs of 1880s and 1890s Chicago.
Why does Field write part of the dream in old-fashioned spelling and language?
He is mimicking the style of real Puritan diaries and court records, which he had recently read in Alice Morse Earle's book about the Sabbath in colonial New England. The old-fashioned language serves as a comedic tool — it makes the everyday aspects of church life (like seating arguments and the cost of liquor at an ordination) come off as absurdly serious.
What is the actual joke of the poem at the end?
The joke here is that Field has taken the time to craft an intricate Puritan narrative centered on guilt and conscience, only to conclude with the simple advice: don't eat pie in the morning. The humor lies in the contrast between the heavy themes and the lighthearted punchline. Plus, he's giving himself a little ribbing for feeling ill from indulging too much over Christmas.
What does Field mean when he says he always has to "preach some little verses" at Christmas?
He suggests that his urge to moralize and his desire to write poetry are intertwined, both peaking during Christmas. Growing up in a religious home, he often felt drawn to preaching — but he channeled that impulse into humorous verse instead. The poem at the end of this piece serves as his Christmas sermon, shared with a playful twist.
Is the bulldog story true?
Field was known for blending fact with fiction, leaving his friends and colleagues often unsure about what was real. The story feels believable — it aligns with what we know about his character — but Field was also adept at crafting his own legend. Even if it didn't unfold exactly as told, it accurately reflects who he was.
What does Field mean by his "Separatist ancestors" sailing in the Mayflower inside him?
He suggests that his Puritan heritage isn’t merely a thing of the past — it’s a vibrant aspect of his personality that comes to the forefront, particularly after he indulges in something enjoyable like Christmas pie. The picture of his ancestors conducting "town-meetings inside of me after feast-day" humorously captures the internal voice of inherited guilt.
Citation
Cite this poem
MLA
Field, Eugene. "Eugene Field." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/eugene-field-eugene-field/.
APA
Field, E. (n.d.). Eugene field. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/eugene-field-eugene-field/
Row A — Thesis
1 ptIn this hybrid prose-and-verse tribute, the speaker, writing sick and self-deprecating from his sickbed, uses Eugene Field's own remembered words and improvised dream-narrative to argue that genuine Christian feeling is not piety but a …
- Row B — Evidence + Commentary4 pts
- Row C — Sophistication1 pt
- Common student errors
Available on any Storgy plan — model paragraphs, band callouts, and common student errors for every poem.
The study desk
Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.
Adjacent texts in the archive
Read next
- In the same key
Christmas Bells
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Read & analyze - In the same key
The Oxen
Thomas Hardy
Read & analyze - In the same key
The Lamb
William Blake
Read & analyze - In the same key
Fern Hill
Dylan Thomas
Read & analyze - In the same key
Piano
D. H. Lawrence
Read & analyze - In the same key
Ode on a Grecian Urn
John Keats
Read & analyze