BALLAD OF WOMEN I LOVE by Eugene Field: Summary, Meaning & Analysis
A lovesick narrator lists the women he "loves," but here's the twist: he's not actually in love with the women; he's enamored with their antique dishes and pottery.
The poem
Prudence Mears hath an old blue plate Hid away in an oaken chest, And a Franklin platter of ancient date Beareth Amandy Baker's crest; What times soever I've been their guest, Says I to myself in an undertone: "Of womenfolk, it must be confessed, These do I love, and these alone." Well, again, in the Nutmeg State, Dorothy Pratt is richly blest With a relic of art and a land effete-- A pitcher of glass that's cut, not pressed. And a Washington teapot is possessed Down in Pelham by Marthy Stone-- Think ye now that I say in jest "These do I love, and these alone?" Were Hepsy Higgins inclined to mate, Or Dorcas Eastman prone to invest In Cupid's bonds, they could find their fate In the bootless bard of Crockery Quest. For they've heaps of trumpery--so have the rest Of those spinsters whose ware I'd like to own; You can see why I say with such certain zest, "These do I love, and these alone."
A lovesick narrator lists the women he "loves," but here's the twist: he's not actually in love with the women; he's enamored with their antique dishes and pottery. It’s a comic poem where the punchline reveals that each woman he mentions just so happens to own a prized piece of crockery. Field delivers the joke with a straight face through three stanzas, allowing the absurdity to escalate until the final stanza drives the point home.
Line-by-line
Prudence Mears hath an old blue plate / Hid away in an oaken chest,
Well, again, in the Nutmeg State, / Dorothy Pratt is richly blest
Were Hepsy Higgins inclined to mate, / Or Dorcas Eastman prone to invest
Tone & mood
Playful and self-deprecating throughout. Field takes on the serious tone of a ballad enthusiast but then humorously undermines it with collector's jargon and precise details. The humor is dry and builds over time—the more seriously the narrator delivers it, the funnier it becomes. There's no ill will toward the women; the punchline is all about the narrator's own shortcomings.
Symbols & metaphors
- The blue plate and antique crockery — The dishes symbolize everything a romantic partner typically values in someone they cherish — beauty, rarity, age, and origin. By replacing a person with pottery, Field flips the traditional love ballad conventions on their head.
- The oaken chest — A locked chest evokes thoughts of hidden treasure and secrets, reminiscent of the language found in love poems about buried emotions. In this case, it simply refers to someone carefully storing their good china, creating an image that's both amusing and unexpectedly sweet.
- The "bootless bard of Crockery Quest" — "Bootless" refers to something that is futile or unrewarding. The narrator sees himself as a failed knight on a comical quest—a parody of the courtly lover chasing an impossible ideal. In this case, his ideal is a teapot from Washington.
- The Nutmeg State (Connecticut) — A regional nickname that evokes ideas of Yankee thrift, trading skills, and a knack for collecting. Including it in the poem indicates that this antique-hunting world is a familiar, somewhat humorous subculture for Field's readers.
Historical context
Eugene Field (1850–1895) was a newspaper columnist and poet from Chicago, best remembered for his sentimental children's poems like "Wynken, Blynken, and Nod." However, he was also a skilled humorist, and this poem reflects that humorous side of his work. In the late nineteenth century, many middle-class Americans developed a fascination with collecting antiques, particularly colonial-era pottery, glassware, and ceramics. Items linked to historical figures such as George Washington were especially sought after. Field's readers would have been familiar with the collector's lingo — cut versus pressed glass, Franklin ware, Washington teapots — and would recognize that the narrator's "love" referred to the obsession of a china-hunter rather than a romantic interest. The ballad's structure, featuring a repeated refrain and named female characters, parodies the medieval and Romantic-era love ballads that Field's audience was well-acquainted with.
FAQ
It's a comic poem about a man who insists he loves certain women, but the punchline is that his affection is really just for their valuable antique pottery and glassware. His "love" is all about their collections, not about the women themselves.
"Bootless" is an old term that means something like futile or unrewarded. A "bard" refers to a poet. In this context, the narrator humorously labels himself a failed poet on a silly quest for crockery — it’s a playful jab that pokes fun at the language typically found in knightly romance.
Cut glass is crafted by hand through grinding and cutting, which makes it more expensive and sought after. In contrast, pressed glass is created by pressing molten glass into a mold, resulting in a cheaper, mass-produced product. When the narrator notes that Dorothy Pratt's pitcher is "cut, not pressed," it reveals that he is a serious collector with a keen eye for detail.
It's a nickname for Connecticut that comes from a joke about how clever traders in the state were said to sell wooden nutmegs as if they were genuine. By the late 1800s, it had become a well-known regional term, and Field uses it to add a distinct, authentic American touch to the poem.
Not really. The joke is directed right at the narrator. The women are simply living their lives and enjoying their nice things. It's the narrator's greedy, collector mindset of "love" that the humor is poking fun at.
This refers to a pottery item linked to Benjamin Franklin or created in the style of colonial American ceramics. Antique pieces tied to the Founding Fathers were very popular among collectors in the late 1800s, which is why the narrator finds Amandy Baker so "loveable."
Normally, "trumpery" refers to flashy, worthless junk—items that might seem impressive but lack true value. Field uses it here with a sense of warmth, almost as a term of endearment for the spinsters' collections. This word choice enhances the comic tone by implying that the narrator is aware his obsession is somewhat silly.
A ballad typically narrates a story using repeated stanzas and a refrain, often focusing on themes of love or adventure. Field takes that classic structure — complete with named characters, a recurring closing line, and an old-fashioned tone — and infuses it with humor about collecting antiques rather than sincere romance. In this case, the structure itself becomes the punchline.