A Misconception
B, taught by Pope to do his good by stealth,
'Twixt participle and noun no difference feeling,
In office placed to serve the Commonwealth,
Does himself all the good he can by stealing.
The Annotated Edition
A Misconception by James Russell Lowell
Read aloud in ~1 minOpen reading mode →
A Misconception is a clever four-line joke targeting a corrupt official referred to simply as "B." He has misunderstood Alexander Pope's well-known advice to "do good by stealth," interpreting "stealth" as theft instead of quiet virtue.
- Core theme
- Art
Study actions
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
A Misconception is a clever four-line joke targeting a corrupt official referred to simply as "B." He has misunderstood Alexander Pope's well-known advice to "do good by stealth," interpreting "stealth" as theft instead of quiet virtue. The entire poem plays on the grammatical mix-up between a participle and a noun, delivering a punch line that hits hard.
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
B, taught by Pope to do his good by stealth, / 'Twixt participle and noun no difference feeling,
Editor's note
Lowell sets up the joke in these two lines. He references Alexander Pope's couplet from *Epistle to Dr. Arbuthnot*: "Do good by stealth, and blush to find it fame." Pope suggested that a genuinely virtuous person performs good deeds quietly, without looking for recognition. However, B can't distinguish between *stealing* (a participle, a verb form that describes an action) and *stealth* (a noun, indicating a quality or manner). This grammatical confusion drives the entire poem.
In office placed to serve the Commonwealth, / Does himself all the good he can by stealing.
Editor's note
Here the punch line hits hard. B holds a public office—he's meant to serve the people—but he has warped Pope's moral guidance into a justification for personal gain. "Does himself all the good he can" turns the original virtue, which is meant to be outward-focused, into blatant self-interest, while "by stealing" harshly replaces "by stealth" with stark directness. The humor operates on two levels simultaneously: B is both grammatically illiterate and morally corrupt, and Lowell implies that these two shortcomings are essentially the same.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
The tone is dry, sardonic, and precise — it reflects someone who sees corruption as more laughable than infuriating. Lowell remains composed the entire time; there’s no shouting, just a carefully crafted setup and a deadpan delivery of the punch line. The wit feels sharp and calculated rather than angry.
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- Stealth vs. Stealing
- The similarity between *stealth* and *stealing* serves as the poem's key device. For Pope, stealth represents the quiet humility of doing good deeds anonymously. In contrast, stealing embodies the opposite moral stance. B's mix-up of these two words highlights how corrupt individuals often disguise their self-interest with virtuous language.
- The Participle and the Noun
- Grammar serves as a metaphor for moral reasoning here. Someone who can't tell the difference between a verb (an action, something performed) and a noun (a quality, something owned) also struggles to differentiate between doing good and just possessing goodness. This grammatical mistake reflects a corresponding ethical misstep.
- "B"
- The single initial keeps the target both specific and universal. It points to a real person that Lowell had in mind while also representing any corrupt officeholder at any time. This anonymity makes the satire timeless.
- Pope's teaching
- Alexander Pope represents the essence of true moral culture, embodying the Augustan ideals of virtue and civic duty. B's misunderstanding of Pope reflects not only personal dishonesty but also a deeper inability to grasp the ethical legacy of our literary heritage.
§06Form & structure
Form & structure
- Meter
- iambic pentameter
- Rhyme
- ABAB
§07Historical context
Historical context
James Russell Lowell (1819–1891) was a leading American literary figure of the nineteenth century—poet, critic, editor of *The Atlantic Monthly*, and later U.S. Ambassador to Spain and Britain. He was a passionate abolitionist and a keen satirist of political hypocrisy, most notably in *The Biglow Papers* (1848). *A Misconception* is part of the epigrammatic tradition he inherited from the English Augustans, particularly Alexander Pope, who is the poem's direct subject. The target of the poem, referred to only as "B," was likely a specific political figure familiar to Lowell's readers, though we can't definitively identify who that was. This piece showcases the era's vibrant culture of verse satire that critiqued public corruption—a genre that spanned from Pope through Byron and into the American periodical press of the 1800s.
§08FAQ
Questions readers ask
What is the poem actually about?
It’s a satirical joke about a corrupt public official who embezzles from the very people he’s meant to serve. The humor lies in his misunderstanding of a well-known line by Alexander Pope: he mixes up stealth (acting quietly and humbly) with stealing (taking what isn’t his).
What does Lowell mean by 'participle and noun'?
Stealing is a participle, which means it's a verb that describes an action. Stealth is a noun, referring to a quality or way of doing something. B struggles to distinguish between these two words, and this grammatical mix-up reflects his moral confusion: he can't see the line between quietly doing good and just taking things for himself.
Who is Pope, and what line is Lowell referring to?
Alexander Pope (1688–1744) was a prominent English poet during the Augustan age. The line that Lowell references is from Pope's Epistle to Dr. Arbuthnot: "Do good by stealth, and blush to find it fame." This suggests that genuinely virtuous individuals perform good deeds without wanting attention. However, Lowell's B has entirely twisted that advice.
Who is 'B'?
Lowell uses just the initial, a common satirical technique of the time — specific enough to suggest a real target but vague enough to sidestep a libel case and give the poem a universal quality. Scholars haven't confirmed the exact identity of B, but it's clear that the poem depicts a corrupt official, whether elected or appointed.
What form is the poem written in?
It's a four-line epigram written in iambic pentameter, following an ABAB rhyme scheme. The structure is neat and traditional, taken straight from the English Augustan style that Pope excelled in. This tight form complements the succinctness of the joke perfectly.
What does 'Commonwealth' mean here?
In this context, Commonwealth refers to the public good — the community of citizens and the shared resources and institutions that belong to everyone. B has been appointed to serve that public interest, so his theft is a double betrayal: personal dishonesty and civic corruption.
Is this poem funny, or is Lowell genuinely angry?
Both elements are present, but the humor carries the weight. Lowell's satire comes across as cool and precise, rather than heated and indignant. The joke hits so effectively that it renders the corruption almost absurd. This is a purposeful rhetorical choice: ridicule can be far more damaging than outrage.
What is the poem's main message?
Corrupt officials don’t just steal money; they also corrupt the language of virtue to excuse their actions. B has taken a genuine moral teaching and warped it into a cover story for theft. Lowell argues that poor reading and poor ethics are closely linked.
Citation
Cite this poem
MLA
Lowell, James Russell. "A Misconception." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/a-misconception-james-russell-lowell/.
APA
Lowell, J. R. (n.d.). A misconception. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/a-misconception-james-russell-lowell/
The study desk
Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.
Adjacent texts in the archive
Read next