Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis

Reba

in Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison

Reba is Pilate Dead's daughter and Hagar's mother in Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon. She plays a secondary yet vivid role in the matriarchal household shared by the three women on Darling Street in Michigan. Reba's most notable characteristic is her remarkable, almost supernatural luck—she wins contests and raffles with surprising frequency, most notably the Sears & Roebuck raffle for a diamond ring, which she readily gives away without much concern for material possessions. This impulsive generosity reflects her mother Pilate's way of living outside traditional social norms; however, while Pilate's freedom is based on spiritual insight, Reba's stems from a nearly childlike, unthinking openness to life.

Reba's journey is mainly shaped by her relationships rather than her own decisions. She is a caring, if emotionally burdened, mother to Hagar, and her inability to refuse Hagar anything—including money from pawning the diamond ring—unintentionally fuels Hagar's obsessive, self-destructive chase after Milkman. When Hagar eventually succumbs to heartbreak and shame, Reba's grief is deep and wordless, highlighting her emotional complexity beneath her seemingly carefree demeanor.

Reba also shows fierce protectiveness: when a man mistreats her, Pilate steps in with a knife, and Reba's passive acceptance of abuse reveals her vulnerability alongside her luck. She is warm, sensual, and overly generous—a woman whose gifts flow outward so freely that she struggles to shield herself or her daughter from devastation. Ultimately, Reba embodies the tragic limitations of unconditional love that lacks wisdom.

About this character

Form
Novel
Author
Toni Morrison
First published
1977

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Reba?

Reba Dead is the middle generation of the three-woman household on Darling Street in Southside, Michigan—daughter to Pilate and mother to Hagar. Morrison positions her structurally and symbolically between the novel's two poles of female experience: Pilate's preternatural self-possession and Hagar's fatal dependency. While Pilate carries no navel and walks the earth unburdened by social convention through deliberate spiritual will, Reba's freedom is altogether more accidental. She is blessed—or possibly cursed—with extraordinary luck, winning prizes and raffles so consistently that it reads less like coincidence than a strange cosmic favoritism. The most consequential of these wins is the Sears & Roebuck first-prize diamond ring, an object whose fate becomes one of the novel's quiet tragedies. Reba is warm, sensual, and constitutionally incapable of hoarding anything: money, affection, or the ring itself. She gives everything away before she has time to consider whether she should.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Reba's arc and motivation?

Reba does not drive the plot in the way Milkman or even Hagar does, but she undergoes a quiet, devastating emotional arc nonetheless. At the novel's opening, she inhabits Darling Street as a kind of abundant, careless presence—her luck a running source of neighborhood wonder. Her motivation, to the extent that it can be named, is simply love: she desires to please and to give, especially to Hagar. When Hagar's obsession with Milkman deepens into crisis, Reba's response aligns with her character. She pawns the diamond ring without hesitation to fund Hagar's doomed shopping expedition—the attempt to buy new clothes, new beauty, a new self capable of recapturing Milkman's love. The act is moving precisely because it is so unreflective. Reba never calculates the consequences. By the time Hagar dies of heartbreak and shame, Reba's arc resolves not in wisdom or transformation but in grief so large it has no adequate language. Her silence at the end speaks to emotional depths that her cheerful surface had always concealed.

03·Key moments

What are Reba's key moments?

  • The Sears & Roebuck raffle win: Reba's diamond ring prize establishes her luck as a defining trait and introduces the object that will later be sacrificed. Her nonchalance about the prize already signals that she attaches no lasting value to material goods—or to anything she possesses.
  • Pilate's knife intervention: When an abusive lover mistreats Reba, it is Pilate who confronts him with a knife, not Reba herself. The scene is crucial: it reveals Reba's passivity and vulnerability even as it illustrates Pilate's fierce protectiveness. Reba accepts danger the way she accepts luck—without much agency.
  • Pawning the ring for Hagar: Reba sells the diamond so Hagar can shop for the clothes she believes will make Milkman love her again. The gesture is an act of pure maternal devotion, yet it directly accelerates Hagar's unraveling, making Reba's generosity complicit in her daughter's destruction.
  • Grief after Hagar's death: Reba's mourning is wordless and consuming. Alongside Pilate, she sings over Hagar's body, and her devastation closes off any notion that her easygoing nature was ever shallow. The grief is the measure of the love, and the love was always enormous.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Reba's most important relationships?

Reba and Pilate share a household, a philosophy of living outside bourgeois respectability, and a bond of mutual dependency—though the dependency runs more heavily in one direction. Pilate is Reba's protector, interpreter, and moral compass; without Pilate's grounding wisdom, Reba's openness becomes exposure. The knife scene encapsulates this perfectly: Reba suffers, and Pilate acts. Their relationship is intimate and largely harmonious, yet it quietly underscores Reba's incapacity for self-protection.

With Hagar, Reba mirrors and amplifies Pilate's maternal love, but without its governing intelligence. She cannot refuse her daughter anything—money, comfort, validation—and this unconditional yes becomes a form of harm. Pawning the ring is the starkest illustration: an act of love that removes the last practical obstacle between Hagar and her own destruction. Reba loves Hagar with everything she has and it is not enough, because love without wisdom cannot save.

Milkman Dead (Macon III) is largely an abstraction in Reba's world—the man her daughter is destroying herself over. Reba's sacrifices orbit his carelessness without ever touching him. Macon Dead II's contempt for Pilate's household encompasses Reba as part of a lineage he considers disreputable, reinforcing her marginalization from the novel's more socially legible world.

05·Connected characters

How is Reba connected to the other characters?

Pilate Dead

Reba is Pilate's daughter and most intimate companion. They share a home and a way of life outside bourgeois norms. Pilate physically defends Reba from an abusive lover, knife in hand, demonstrating the fierce, protective bond that flows from mother to daughter even as Reba remains emotionally dependent on Pilate's stronger will.

Hagar Dead

Reba is Hagar's mother and her most enabling supporter. She pawns her prized diamond ring to give Hagar money to buy clothes and win back Milkman, an act of boundless generosity that accelerates Hagar's tragic spiral. Reba cannot refuse Hagar anything, and her unconditional love, lacking Pilate's grounding wisdom, contributes to Hagar's destruction.

Milkman Dead (Macon Dead III)

Milkman is the object of Hagar's obsession and thus a peripheral but consequential presence in Reba's life. Reba's sacrifices—including pawning the diamond ring—are made in service of Hagar's doomed love for him, making Milkman indirectly responsible for much of the household's suffering.

Macon Dead II

Macon Dead II is Reba's uncle by blood (Pilate's brother), though the two households are estranged. His contempt for Pilate's family extends to Reba, whom he regards as part of a disreputable, shameful lineage he wishes to disown.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Reba

What is Reba's most famous trait in Song of Solomon?

Reba is renowned for her almost supernatural luck, winning contests and raffles with uncanny frequency. Her most significant prize is a Sears & Roebuck first-prize diamond ring, which she gives away without hesitation. Morrison frames this luck ambivalently: Reba wins abundantly but cannot hold onto anything, converting her good fortune into her daughter Hagar's ruin rather than into lasting security for herself or her family.

What happens to Reba's diamond ring?

Reba pawns the diamond ring to give Hagar money for a shopping trip meant to win back Milkman's love. This act reflects pure, unreflective maternal devotion, but it removes the last practical obstacle between Hagar and her own destruction. The ring's fate stands as one of the novel's quiet tragedies—an object of extraordinary luck converted into fuel for an obsession that ultimately kills Hagar.

How does Reba's relationship with Pilate differ from her relationship with Hagar?

With Pilate, Reba is a protected dependent: Pilate physically defends her from an abusive lover, knife in hand, and provides the grounding wisdom that Reba herself lacks. With Hagar, their roles reverse—Reba becomes the indulgent, enabling mother who cannot refuse her daughter anything. Pilate's love for Reba is fierce and governing; Reba's love for Hagar is boundless but unguided, and this difference proves catastrophic.

Why can't Reba protect herself from abusive partners in Song of Solomon?

Reba accepts danger the same way she accepts luck—passively and without much agency. When a man mistreats her, it is Pilate who steps in with a knife, not Reba. Morrison suggests that Reba's openness to life, the same quality that makes her warm and generous, also leaves her unable to defend herself, so her freedom becomes accidental rather than willed.

Is Reba responsible for Hagar's tragic fate?

Morrison frames Reba's role as tragic complicity rather than deliberate wrongdoing. By never refusing Hagar anything—money, validation, or the proceeds from the pawned diamond ring—Reba removes every check on Hagar's self-destructive obsession with Milkman. Her unconditional love, lacking Pilate's wisdom, functions as enablement. Morrison invites readers to consider whether love without judgment can cause harm, even when intentions remain pure.

How does Reba react to Hagar's death?

Reba's grief is wordless and consuming; she sings over Hagar's body alongside Pilate, and her devastation reveals emotional depths her earlier cheerfulness had concealed. Morrison employs Reba's silence at this crisis point to retroactively reframe her easygoing nature as a surface beneath which an enormous capacity for love—and for suffering—had always existed.

What is Reba's relationship to Macon Dead II in Song of Solomon?

Macon Dead II is Reba's uncle—Pilate's estranged brother—but the two households share no warmth. His contempt for Pilate's family extends fully to Reba, whom he regards as part of a disreputable lineage he wishes to disown. Reba remains largely peripheral to his world, reinforcing her marginalization from the novel's more socially legible, patriarchal power structures.

How does Reba compare to Pilate as a mother figure in Song of Solomon?

Both Pilate and Reba exist outside bourgeois social norms and love fiercely, but Pilate's freedom is grounded in deliberate spiritual will while Reba's is accidental and unthinking. Morrison positions Reba as the cautionary middle generation: more constrained than Pilate yet more giving than is wise, her unconditional generosity ultimately illustrates that love alone, without wisdom, does not prevent tragedy.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Luck as ambivalent gift

    Argue that Reba's supernatural luck functions as irony—she wins prizes she cannot hold onto and possesses abundance she converts into her daughter's ruin, suggesting Morrison interrogates whether fortune is ever straightforwardly fortunate.

  • Unconditional love as enablement

    Examine how Reba's inability to withhold anything from Hagar complicates conventional readings of maternal love; does Morrison frame Reba's devotion as a form of moral failure, or as tragedy without culpability?

  • The three-woman household as alternative kinship

    Analyze Darling Street as a deliberately constructed matriarchal counter-space to Macon Dead II's patriarchal household, considering what Reba's passivity and Pilate's agency together reveal about the possibilities and limits of that counter-space.

  • Generosity versus wisdom in Morrison's female characters

    Compare Reba with Pilate and Hagar to argue that Morrison distinguishes between forms of love, positioning Reba's indiscriminate giving as the novel's cautionary middle ground.

  • Silence and grief as characterization

    Build a thesis on how Reba's wordless mourning after Hagar's death retroactively reframes her earlier cheerfulness, arguing that Morrison uses emotional restraint at the novel's crisis point to reveal the depth of a character who otherwise lives entirely on the surface.

Song of Solomon

Continue

Full study guide →