Prompt 01
Essay task
In Crime and Punishment, Raskolnikov's act of murder stems not from desperation or greed but from his own philosophical theory that categorizes people as "ordinary" and "extraordinary." Write a well-developed argumentative essay in which you examine how Raskolnikov's psychological turmoil following the murder serves as Dostoevsky's critique of utilitarian and Napoleonic "superman" ideology.
In your essay, be sure to:
Your essay should present a clear, defensible thesis and back it up with specific textual evidence.
- Clearly explain Raskolnikov's theory and its moral consequences
- Analyze key moments (such as the murder, his interactions with Sonia, and his dialogues with Porfiry) as evidence for or against your argument
- Explore how guilt, isolation, and eventual confession serve as critiques of ideology
- Consider how Dostoevsky employs characterization, narrative structure, and symbolism to strengthen his argument