The Annotated Edition
Passages of the Preface by Percy Bysshe Shelley
This prose-poem is taken from Shelley's preface to *Adonais* (1821), his tribute to John Keats.
- Core theme
- Art
Study actions
§01Quick summary
What this poem is about
§02Themes
Recurring themes
§03Line by line
Stanza by stanza, with notes
...the expression of my indignation and sympathy. I will allow myself / a first and last word on the subject of calumny as it relates to me.
Editor's note
Shelley begins by stating that he will address the slander aimed at him—just this once. The term *calumny* (meaning false and damaging accusation) indicates his sense of being unjustly targeted. He presents his remarks as a personal defense and a principled stand, steering clear of any self-pity.
As an author I have dared and invited censure. If I understand myself, / I have written neither for profit nor for fame.
Editor's note
Shelley acknowledges that he anticipated backlash from his radical ideas—he even *invited* it. However, he asserts that his motivations were never about financial gain or fame. He wrote, he explains, to create a connection of sympathy with others, fueled by a profound love for humanity. This reflects a classic Romantic notion: the poet as a selfless servant of emotion.
These compositions (excepting the tragedy of 'The Cenci'...) are insufficiently...commendation than perhaps they deserve...
Editor's note
Shelley recognizes that his works have garnered some praise, but nothing close to mainstream success. He makes an exception for *The Cenci*, which he approached more as a technical exercise than an emotional expression — a rare instance of him reflecting on his craft. The gap between the critical acclaim and the public's indifference clearly affects him.
As a man, I shrink from notice and regard; the ebb and flow of the world vexes me; / I desire to be left in peace.
Editor's note
Here, Shelley distinguishes between his public persona as an author and his private identity. Personally, he avoids the spotlight — the clamor of social life drains him. The subsequent list (persecution, contumely, calumny, domestic conspiracy, legal oppression) feels like a record of genuine suffering: Shelley lost custody of his children and faced relentless criticism for his atheism and political views.
Reviewers, with some rare exceptions, are a most stupid and malignant race. / As a bankrupt thief turns thieftaker in despair, so an unsuccessful author turns critic.
Editor's note
This is the most quotable passage in the preface. Shelley's disdain for critics is both sharp and humorous: a failed writer turns into a critic just like a failed thief becomes an informer—driven by spite and desperation. He then shifts to feeling for any young, ambitious writer who takes these jabs personally, unaware that negative reviews fade away quickly.
The offence of this poor victim seems to have consisted solely in his intimacy with Leigh Hunt, Mr. Hazlitt, and some other enemies of despotism and superstition.
Editor's note
Shelley begins to defend a specific unnamed individual—most likely Keats or someone from the Hunt circle—who faced criticism merely for associating with the wrong crowd. Both Leigh Hunt and William Hazlitt became targets of conservative publications such as *Blackwood's* and the *Quarterly Review*. By using the phrase 'enemies of despotism and superstition,' Shelley indicates that he views the literary conflict as fundamentally political.
I knew personally but little of Keats; but on the news of his situation / I wrote to him, suggesting the propriety of trying the Italian climate...
Editor's note
Shelley ends with a poignant reference to Keats, whose tuberculosis was getting worse. Shelley had invited him to Italy, but Keats turned it down and passed away in Rome in February 1821. The sense of regret is subtle yet profound. This section links the preface directly to *Adonais*, the elegy Shelley composed in honor of Keats, providing the entire piece with its emotional foundation.
§04Tone & mood
How this poem feels
§05Symbols & metaphors
Symbols & metaphors
- Calumny
- False accusation represents the entire system of conservative literary and legal culture that Shelley believed had aimed at him — from negative reviews to the court cases that took away his children.
- The bankrupt thief turned thieftaker
- A striking comparison for the unsuccessful writer who turns into a critic. It suggests that, in Shelley's view, criticism is more about revenge than true judgment — stemming from envy and failure rather than authentic appreciation.
- The Italian climate
- Shelley's invitation to Keats to visit Italy serves as a practical medical recommendation and embodies the Romantic notion of the south as a land of warmth, beauty, and creative rejuvenation. Keats's decision to decline adds a layer of tragedy to this symbol.
- Ebb and flow of the world
- The tidal metaphor reflects Shelley's view of public life as restless and indifferent — a force that drains rather than uplifts a person. This reinforces his expressed wish to step back from the spotlight.
- Leigh Hunt and Hazlitt as 'enemies of despotism'
- These real names symbolize a community under attack — radical writers whose friendship was seen as a crime by the conservative establishment.
§06Historical context
Historical context
§07FAQ
Questions readers ask
Is this actually a poem? It reads like prose.
It’s prose — more specifically, the preface that Shelley wrote for his elegy Adonais. This piece is examined as a literary work in its own right due to its passionate, nearly lyrical quality and its significance as a representation of Romantic poetic values. You might consider it a prose-poem or a literary manifesto.
Who is Shelley talking about when he mentions 'this poor victim'?
The immediate target of the hostile reviews Shelley discusses was probably a writer from the Leigh Hunt circle—possibly Keats or someone similar. Shelley's larger argument is that anyone linked to Hunt and Hazlitt faced attacks not for their literary work but for political reasons.
Did a bad review really kill Keats?
No — Keats died of tuberculosis, a physical illness. However, Shelley (along with Byron, who famously quipped about it) thought that the harsh 1818 critique of Endymion by the Quarterly Review had devastated Keats emotionally. Today, many scholars disagree with this view, and Keats was actually more resilient about criticism than Shelley acknowledged. Still, this myth fueled much of the intensity in Adonais.
What does 'contumely' mean?
Contemptuous and insulting treatment is designed to humiliate rather than just criticize. Shelley pairs it with 'persecution' and 'calumny' to create an image of ongoing, intentional cruelty instead of genuine disagreement.
Why does Shelley say he wrote 'neither for profit nor for fame'?
This is a central idea of Romanticism: true poetry arises from authentic emotions and a longing to connect with others, rather than from commercial interests or ego. Shelley is also responding to accusations that his bold work was merely an attempt to gain fame.
What is 'The Cenci' and why does Shelley treat it differently from his other work?
The Cenci (1819) is a verse tragedy inspired by a real story of incest and murder during the Renaissance in Italy. Shelley noted that he wrote it to challenge his skills as a dramatist rather than to convey his deepest emotions—viewing it more as a craft exercise than a personal expression, which sets it apart from works like Prometheus Unbound.
Who were Leigh Hunt and Hazlitt, and why were they controversial?
Leigh Hunt was a poet, essayist, and editor who had already spent time in jail for libeling the Prince Regent. William Hazlitt was an insightful and confrontational critic known for his radical political views. Both were linked to what conservative journals derisively termed the 'Cockney School'—a dismissive label for London-based writers of lower social status who had the audacity to discuss beauty, politics, and poetry without an Oxbridge background.
What happened to Shelley after he wrote this?
Shelley drowned in the Gulf of Spezia, Italy, in July 1822, just under a year after he wrote this preface. He was only twenty-nine. His friends, including Byron, cremated his body on the beach. After leaving England in 1818, he never returned.
Citation
Cite this poem
MLA
Shelley, Percy Bysshe. "Passages of the Preface." Storgy, https://storgy.com/poems/passages-of-the-preface-percy-bysshe-shelley/.
APA
Shelley, P. B. (n.d.). Passages of the preface. Storgy. https://storgy.com/poems/passages-of-the-preface-percy-bysshe-shelley/
Row A — Thesis
1 ptIn 'Passages of the Preface,' Shelley constructs a dual self-portrait — the wounded idealist and the defiant prophet — to argue that the poet who writes from 'ardent and unbounded love' for humanity is inevitably destroyed by the very …
- Row B — Evidence + Commentary4 pts
- Row C — Sophistication1 pt
- Common student errors
Available on any Storgy plan — model paragraphs, band callouts, and common student errors for every poem.
The study desk
Teaching materials and reference tools prepared for this poem.
Adjacent texts in the archive
Read next
- In the same key
Adonais
Percy Bysshe Shelley
Read & analyze - In the same key
Lycidas
John Milton
Read & analyze - In the same key
Ode to a Nightingale
John Keats
Read & analyze - In the same key
Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard
Thomas Gray
Read & analyze - In the same key
Epistle to Dr Arbuthnot
Alexander Pope
Read & analyze - In the same key
To a Skylark
Percy Bysshe Shelley
Read & analyze