Prompt 01
Essay task
In Hard Times, Charles Dickens critiques the rigid philosophy of Utilitarianism, which prioritizes facts, reason, and economic productivity over human experience. He illustrates how this ideology dehumanizes individuals and undermines their capacity for imagination, compassion, and happiness. In a well-structured essay, analyze how Dickens employs at least two of the following literary elements to convey this critique: characterization, symbolism, setting, or narrative tone.
Requirements
- Develop a clear, arguable thesis that outlines Dickens's critique and the specific literary techniques you will explore.
- Support your argument with textual evidence (direct quotations and paraphrases) from the novel.
- Explore how Dickens portrays the world of Coketown and the Gradgrind household as representations of Utilitarian ideology.
- Consider at least one counterargument or complication — for instance, whether Dickens provides a convincing alternative to the system he critiques.
- Your essay should consist of 4–6 paragraphs (or as specified by your teacher).
Suggested Thesis Frame
> Through his use of [literary technique #1] and [literary technique #2], Dickens reveals that a society driven solely by facts and utility ultimately [claim about human consequence], suggesting that [broader thematic statement].
Guiding Questions to Consider Before Writing
- How do characters like Thomas Gradgrind, Sissy Jupe, and Stephen Blackpool embody or challenge Utilitarian values?
- What does Coketown's industrial landscape represent regarding the human cost of industrialization?
- In what ways does Dickens's narrative voice influence the reader's empathy and moral perspective?
- Does the novel's conclusion provide a satisfactory critique of the system it opposes, or does it fall short?