Billy Budd, Sailor

# Essay Prompt: *Billy Budd* by Herman Melville **Prompt:** In *Billy Budd*, Herman Melville explores the complex tension between natural law and institutional law through the experiences of the innocent sailor Billy Budd. In a structured essay, argue that Captain Vere's choice to execute Billy Budd represents a **tragic yet intentional sacrifice of moral justice for the sake of social order**, rather than a personal moral failing. Use specific examples from the text to support your argument, addressing at least **two** of the following elements: - Captain Vere's reasoning and internal struggle - The symbolism of Billy Budd as a Christ-like or Adamic figure - The Articles of War as a tool of institutional authority - Claggart's role as a representation of "natural depravity" **Requirements:** - Create a clear, debatable thesis in your introduction - Back up your argument with a close reading of at least **three** passages from the novella - Recognize and counter a **counterargument** (for example, that Vere acts out of fear or ambition) - Conclude by considering what Melville implies about the **cost of civilization and justice** > *Suggested length: 4–6 paragraphs (approx. 800–1,200 words)*

ap_lit · ib_lang_lit · common_core_ela

# Essay Prompt: *Billy Budd* by Herman Melville **Prompt:** In *Billy Budd*, Herman Melville explores the deep conflict between natural law and institutional law through the destinies of his characters. In a well-structured essay, argue that Captain Vere's choice to condemn Billy Budd to death ultimately highlights the tragic clash between moral innocence and a rigid social order. Use specific evidence from the novella—including the characterizations of Billy, Claggart, and Vere, as well as the drumhead trial scene—to support your argument. Reflect on how Melville employs irony, symbolism, and narrative ambiguity to complicate any straightforward moral assessment of Vere's decision. **Guiding Questions to Consider:** - What does Billy Budd symbolize, and how does his "innocence" play a role in the story? - In what ways does Claggart's malice contrast with Billy's goodness, and what does their conflict reveal about human nature? - Is Captain Vere a tragic hero, a moral coward, or something more nuanced? Support your interpretation. - What is Melville's ultimate perspective on justice, law, and individual conscience? **Requirements:** - At least 5 paragraphs (introduction, 3 body paragraphs, conclusion) - Include a clear and arguable thesis statement - Use textual evidence with appropriate citations - Address at least one counterargument

ap_lit · ib_lang_lit · common_core_ela