Skip to content
Storgy

The Annotated Edition

THE HEMLOCK TREE. by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

A speaker likens a loyal hemlock tree to an unfaithful lover who is only present during happy moments but vanishes when difficulties arise.

Poet
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
The PoemFull text

THE HEMLOCK TREE.

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

O hemlock tree! O hemlock tree! how faithful are thy branches! Green not alone in summer time, But in the winter's frost and rime! O hemlock tree! O hemlock tree! how faithful are thy branches! O maiden fair! O maiden fair! how faithless is thy bosom! To love me in prosperity, And leave me in adversity! O maiden fair! O maiden fair! how faithless is thy bosom! The nightingale, the nightingale, thou tak'st for thine example! So long as summer laughs she sings, But in the autumn spreads her wings. The nightingale, the nightingale, thou tak'st for thine example! The meadow brook, the meadow brook, is mirror of thy falsehood! It flows so long as falls the rain, In drought its springs soon dry again. The meadow brook, the meadow brook, is mirror of thy falsehood!

Public domain

Sourced from Project Gutenberg

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

A speaker likens a loyal hemlock tree to an unfaithful lover who is only present during happy moments but vanishes when difficulties arise. Following this, the speaker makes two more comparisons: a nightingale that falls silent when summer fades and a brook that runs dry without rain. These images emphasize the depth of the speaker's disappointment. It's a brief, lyrical poem capturing the pain of being abandoned by someone you believed in.

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

  1. O hemlock tree! O hemlock tree! how faithful are thy branches!

    Editor's note

    The speaker begins by celebrating the hemlock tree, which retains its green color during the warm summer and cold winter. This repeated exclamation creates a vibe reminiscent of a folk song or hymn. The tree serves as an example of steadfastness — it remains unchanged by the seasons, and this reliability will soon be compared to the fickle nature of a lover.

  2. O maiden fair! O maiden fair! how faithless is thy bosom!

    Editor's note

    The poem takes a sudden turn. The musical structure that once celebrated the tree now openly confronts the maiden. When it says 'Thy bosom,' it refers to her heart and inner self, rather than just her looks. She loved the speaker during good times — when life was smooth and fulfilling — but left when tough times hit. This parallel structure emphasizes the contrast, making it feel like a judgment.

  3. The nightingale, the nightingale, thou tak'st for thine example!

    Editor's note

    The speaker adds another comparison: the nightingale, known for its lovely song, only sings during the summer. When autumn comes, it spreads its wings and departs. According to the speaker, the maiden has chosen this fair-weather bird as her example. The nightingale traditionally represents romantic love in European poetry, so using it as a symbol of *inconstancy* here is a sharp twist.

  4. The meadow brook, the meadow brook, is mirror of thy falsehood!

    Editor's note

    The final stanza introduces a new image: a brook that flows abundantly when there's enough rain but runs dry as soon as drought arrives. The term 'mirror' is crucial—this brook doesn't merely echo the maiden's deception; it reflects it back in perfect clarity. Together, the three natural images (tree, bird, brook) convey a powerful message: nature can be either loyal or unfaithful, and this woman has aligned herself with the latter.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

The tone blends mournfulness with accusation. It carries the flowing, repetitive feel of a folk ballad, creating a sense of resigned sadness instead of intense anger. The speaker isn't shouting; instead, they present their case in a calm, melodic way, asserting their sense of being wronged. While there's bitterness lurking beneath the surface, it remains controlled, almost like a ritual.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

The hemlock tree
Constancy and faithfulness. The hemlock remains green throughout the year, no matter the season, symbolizing loyalty that isn’t affected by changing circumstances.
The nightingale
Fair-weather devotion. Traditionally a symbol of love and song, the nightingale is reimagined here as a creature whose beauty appears only in pleasant conditions — mirroring the maiden directly.
The meadow brook
Hollow promises. The brook appears to be a steady, flowing presence, but it only runs when it receives rain. During drought, it disappears, just like the maiden's love faded when the speaker needed it the most.
Summer and winter / prosperity and adversity
The seasons reflect the ups and downs of life. Summer brings ease and joy, while winter, frost, drought, and autumn symbolize struggle. The poem challenges love through this seasonal cycle and reveals its shortcomings.

§06Historical context

Historical context

Longfellow published this poem as a translation and adaptation of a German folk song, specifically tied to the *Volkslied* tradition, which often uses nature imagery to express human emotions. During the 1820s and 1830s, Longfellow spent time in Germany and was significantly influenced by German Romantic poetry and song. The hemlock tree (German: *Tanne*, commonly translated as fir or hemlock) symbolized steadfastness in that literary tradition. Longfellow's version appeared in his early work and showcases his ongoing interest in introducing European folk forms to American audiences. The poem's refrain structure resembles the call-and-response pattern of oral song, indicating it was designed to be experienced as much as read. It fits within the wider 19th-century Romantic trend of viewing nature as a moral reflection of human behavior.

§07FAQ

Questions readers ask

The poem suggests that real love remains steadfast during tough times, not just in moments of joy. The hemlock tree retains its green leaves in winter, while the maiden faltered in her loyalty when faced with challenges. The speaker draws on nature to emphasize that faithfulness can be achieved — the maiden just decided not to uphold it.

Read next

Poems in the same key

Similar poems

LA BELLE DAME SANS MERCI. — John KeatsNeutral Tones — Thomas HardyODE TO A NIGHTINGALE. — John KeatsAnnabel Lee — Edgar Allan Poe

More by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

Browse all Henry Wadsworth Longfellow poems →

Themes in this poem

Poems about betrayalPoems about lovePoems about naturePoems about sorrow