Skip to content
Storgy

The Reader's Atlas · Compare · Across the Atlantic

The RavenThe Highwayman

Put "The Raven" by Edgar Allan Poe and "The Highwayman" by Alfred Noyes side by side, and the first thing that stands out is the sound: both poems hit you like a persistent knock at the door.

  • Poets

    Edgar Allan Poe / Alfred Noyes

  • Years

    1906

  • Chapter

    Across the Atlantic

§01 The thesis

The Raven & The Highwayman

A reader's case for putting these two side by side — what each carries, and what they argue when they sit on the same page.

Beyond the craft, both poems are Gothic romances featuring men who have lost, or are on the verge of losing, the women they cherish. They each incorporate a single supernatural or heightened image — a talking bird, a moonlit road — that carries significant emotional weight. And both have become the kind of verses that people memorize effortlessly, as the rhythm seeps into your body before the meaning settles in your mind. The key difference lies in their conclusions: Poe's poem leads to a room without an exit, while Noyes's takes you down a road that continues on, even beyond death.

§02 The dialectic axes

The two poems on four axes

Each axis isolates one specific vector — speaker, form, image, closing move — and reads the two poems against each other on that single dimension.

01Speaker

Poem A · The Raven

The speaker in "The Raven" remains unnamed and is deeply introspective, becoming more and more unstable as the poem progresses. He details his psychological breakdown as it happens, starting with calm logic—convincing himself that the tapping sound is merely a visitor—before erupting into anguish, pleading with a bird to stop tormenting his heart. The narrative is confined entirely to his thoughts.

Poem B · The Highwayman

"The Highwayman" features a third-person ballad narrator who observes the action from a distance. This storyteller isn’t involved in the events; they simply recount the tale, lending the poem a grand, cinematic feel. We can visualize the road, the inn, and the soldiers — it's like the camera glides effortlessly through the scene.
02Form

Poem A · The Raven

Poe constructs "The Raven" from 18 six-line stanzas, featuring a tightly woven internal rhyme scheme that feels nearly oppressive. The brief, repetitive refrain at the end of each stanza — "nothing more," followed by "nevermore" — serves like a cell door slamming shut, stanza by stanza.

Poem B · The Highwayman

Noyes employs a two-part ballad structure featuring long, energetic anapestic lines along with a repeating refrain that brings us back to the image of the highwayman riding. This form feels more alive than Poe's; the lines are longer and the stanzas are more spacious, which fits perfectly with a poem centered on movement and open roads.
03Central Image

Poem A · The Raven

The Raven rests on a bust of Pallas — the goddess of wisdom — and remains completely still. This image feels like a cruel joke: wisdom is right there, yet all it can utter is "nevermore." The bird's unmoving presence intensifies the speaker's growing agitation.

Poem B · The Highwayman

The central image in "The Highwayman" features the moonlit road and the rider traveling along it. Noyes paints the moon as "a ghostly galleon tossed upon cloudy seas" and describes the road as "a ribbon of moonlight." These images evoke a romantic and expansive feeling, contrasting sharply with Poe's more claustrophobic and cold imagery.
04Closing Move

Poem A · The Raven

"The Raven" concludes with a sense of complete entrapment. The bird remains perched. The shadow continues to stretch across the floor. The speaker's soul will be lifted — nevermore. Poe shuts every door and window. The poem finishes in the same place it started, but with a deeper darkness.

Poem B · The Highwayman

"The Highwayman" ends with the spirits of the highwayman and Bess riding together under the moonlight. This offers a romantic comfort — love endures beyond death, and the journey continues. Noyes chooses not to let the tale fade into silence, highlighting a key emotional difference between the two poems.

§03 Synthesis & departure

The shared ground and the divergence

Shared

Both poems share a narrative style and a Gothic essence, where the atmosphere—darkness, cold, shadows, moonlight—acts as a character in the story instead of merely serving as a backdrop. Each revolves around a doomed romantic love: in Poe's work, the speaker mourns Lenore, who is already gone; in Noyes's tale, the highwayman loves Bess, who is destined to die before the poem concludes. In both instances, the woman's death serves as the emotional focal point. From a formal perspective, both poems rely on a compelling, relentless meter that captures physical movement—Poe's trochaic octameter strikes like a fist, while Noyes's anapestic lines rattle like hooves on cobblestone. They both incorporate refrains and near-refrains to establish a hypnotic rhythm. Written for a wide popular audience, both poems achieved remarkable success, quickly becoming among the most recited works in the English language shortly after their publication. Additionally, each utilizes a singular recurring image—the Raven perched above the door and the highwayman riding beneath the moon—as a visual anchor that reinforces the poem's emotional theme.

Where they diverge

The most striking difference lies in the direction of movement. "The Raven" portrays a sense of paralysis. The speaker sinks deeper into a cushioned chair while the bird remains still above the door; by the final stanza, his soul "shall be lifted — nevermore." Everything feels like it’s closing in. In contrast, "The Highwayman" propels outward and forward—horses gallop, a body strains against a rope, and a ghost rides on. Even death can’t halt this motion. The second difference is the timeline of love. In Poe's poem, Lenore is already gone before the first line; her absence is the wound that the entire poem explores. In Noyes's poem, the love story unfolds in real time, allowing the reader to witness Bess make her choice. This makes "The Highwayman" tragic in the classical sense—a fall from a height—while "The Raven" is an elegy that has already come to terms with the fall and is simply measuring how far down it goes. Lastly, Noyes provides his lovers with a sort of afterlife together. Poe, on the other hand, offers nothing of the kind. "Nevermore" is the sole answer in his poem.

§04 A reader's order of operations

Which to read first

If you enjoyed the locked-room intensity of "The Raven," you should check out "The Highwayman" next. It takes that same Gothic style and turns it outward, giving you a sense of movement and action. Noyes delivers the galloping rhythm, the tragic romance, and the darkness, but also features multiple characters making genuine choices. It’s like Poe's world, but with the windows flung wide open. If you found your way here after reading "The Highwayman," I recommend diving into "The Raven" for a deeper psychological exploration. Noyes tells you what happens, while Poe immerses you in the experience of the person living through it, hour after sleepless hour.

§05 Reader's questions

On The Raven vs The Highwayman, frequently asked

Answer

They don't typically go together, but you often see them in lessons on narrative poetry, Gothic literature, and the art of poetic repetition. Teachers often use both to demonstrate how a refrain functions in practice.

§06 More from this chapter

British inheritance, American answer

7 comparisons in this chapter

See all chapters →