Skip to content
Storgy

The Reader's Atlas · Compare · War's Witnesses

Come Up from the Fields FatherHome Burial

Two poems, one theme: a family at home dealing with a death that has already occurred before the poem begins.

  • Poets

    Walt Whitman / Robert Frost

  • Years

    1914

  • Chapter

    War's Witnesses

§01 The thesis

Come Up from the Fields Father & Home Burial

A reader's case for putting these two side by side — what each carries, and what they argue when they sit on the same page.

Whitman penned his poem during the Civil War, likely around 1865, and included it in *Drum-Taps*. A letter arrives at an Ohio farm, prompting the family to rush to the door. The letter conveys that Pete will recover, but the poem reveals he is already dead. Frost's "Home Burial," published in *North of Boston* in 1914, depicts a husband and wife on a staircase after burying their infant son. There is no letter to soften the blow; they face each other and are unable to provide comfort. The common thread between the poems is the notion that grief isn't just an emotion — it’s a struggle to communicate. What distinguishes them is how that struggle is conveyed. Whitman approaches loss with an external perspective and tenderness, while Frost immerses you in the confrontation, leaving no comfortable ground to stand on. Together, these two poems offer the most comprehensive portrayal in American poetry of how death affects those who remain at home.

§02 The dialectic axes

The two poems on four axes

Each axis isolates one specific vector — speaker, form, image, closing move — and reads the two poems against each other on that single dimension.

01Speaker

Poem A · Come Up from the Fields Father

Whitman employs a third-person narrator who is both all-knowing and empathetic — he observes the entire Ohio farm, understands that Pete has died, and witnesses the mother’s collapse with a sense of quiet sorrow. The narrator remains emotionally detached; he possesses knowledge that the characters lack, and this insight drives the poem forward.

Poem B · Home Burial

Frost focuses the poem almost entirely on two characters speaking directly to one another. There's a brief framing line — "He saw her from the bottom of the stairs" — but it quickly fades away. What remains is the raw interaction between the husband and wife, each attempting to connect but ultimately missing the mark.
02Form

Poem A · Come Up from the Fields Father

Whitman writes in his signature long, flowing lines, filled with lists of autumn details — grapes, buckwheat, the sky after rain — that seem almost harsh in their beauty once the letter arrives. The structure is open and relaxed, and the lush imagery of nature deepens the mother's sorrow.

Poem B · Home Burial

Frost employs blank verse — unrhymed iambic pentameter — which continually breaks down under the demands of natural speech. Lines often break in the middle of a thought, characters interrupt one another, and the rhythm falters just like in a real argument. The structure seems to strive for order but consistently falls apart.
03Image

Poem A · Come Up from the Fields Father

The central image features a woman leaning against a door jamb, described as having gone "sickly white in the face and dull in the head." Whitman takes his time leading up to this moment, painting a harvest landscape, so that when the mother’s body finally comes into view, her stillness amid all that autumnal richness encapsulates the poem's essence in a single image.

Poem B · Home Burial

Frost's main image centers on the wife's recollection of seeing her husband dig the grave — the spade raising gravel that jumps "up, like that, like that, and lands so lightly." This violent image comes late in the poem, serving as an accusation. To her, the husband's everyday work appeared to be indifference.
04Closing move

Poem A · Come Up from the Fields Father

Whitman concludes in the depths of the mother's emotions: her yearning to "withdraw unnoticed, silent from life," to join Pete in death. The poem spirals inward, into a sorrow so profound that it transforms into a wish for death. There's no debate, no other perspective — only one woman's wish to vanish.

Poem B · Home Burial

Frost concludes with a threat: "I'll follow and bring you back by force. I will!" The wife opens the door wider. Nothing is resolved. The poem halts instead of finishing, mid-action, mid-sentence, as the door continues to swing. The reader is left feeling the chill of the cold draft.

§03 Synthesis & departure

The shared ground and the divergence

Shared

Both poems are set at the entrance of a house — quite literally. Whitman's mother leans against the doorframe, while Frost's wife has her fingers resting on the latch. Neither poem unfolds on a battlefield or at a graveside. The deaths happen off-screen, and the focus remains entirely on those who are still living. Both poems also explore grief as a breakdown in communication. In Whitman's work, the letter is penned in an unusual hand, with fragmented sentences like "gunshot wound in the breast, cavalry skirmish, taken to hospital," leaving the mother with only pieces of information. In Frost's poem, the husband repeatedly misses the mark in his words, and the wife accuses him of not knowing how to express himself. Neither poem allows language to fulfill the needs of the grieving individual. Both are crafted by men envisioning a woman's grief as the emotional core. They also conclude without resolution: Whitman's mother longs for death, while Frost's wife is stepping out the door. The wound remains unhealed. Neither poet provides solace, which is part of what gives these works their lasting impact.

Where they diverge

The biggest difference between the two poems is the point of view, and it changes everything. In Whitman's poem, the narrator observes the family from a distance. He knows Pete is dead before the mother does and reveals this to us. This gap—between the family's understanding and the narrator's knowledge—is where the poem's sorrow resides. It evokes a gentle, elegiac sadness. In contrast, Frost provides no such distance. "Home Burial" relies heavily on dialogue. You hear the husband and wife speaking in real time, interrupting and misunderstanding each other. There's no narrator to determine who is right. The wife's accusation is heart-wrenching: she saw her husband dig their child's grave, then come inside to discuss how long it takes for a birch fence to decay. The husband's plea is equally poignant: "Let me into your grief." Both perspectives hold truth, and Frost doesn't take sides. Whitman's form is expansive, featuring long lines and pastoral imagery, with the Ohio autumn described in vivid detail before the emotional impact hits. Frost's poem, however, is tight and dramatic, crafted in blank verse that resembles overheard conversation. One poem mourns, while the other engages in a fierce argument.

§04 A reader's order of operations

Which to read first

If you enjoyed "Come Up from the Fields Father" and want to dive deeper, check out "Home Burial" for the conversation that Whitman never allows his characters to have. In Whitman's poem, the mother endures her pain in silence, while Frost's wife struggles to express herself and goes unheard. Both pieces explore similar emotional themes, but they do so at very different intensities. On the other hand, if you started with "Home Burial" and are looking for more, turn to Whitman for the compassion that Frost keeps at bay. Whitman invites you to grieve alongside him. He takes his time, paints a picture of the autumn farm, and conveys the full weight of the mother's sorrow without any conflict over it. It's the same heartache, but approached with a gentler touch.

§05 Reader's questions

On Come Up from the Fields Father vs Home Burial, frequently asked

Answer

Yes, often — particularly in American literature survey courses and in sections on elegy or war poetry. This pairing is effective because both poems focus on personal grief, and the difference between Whitman's lyrical narration and Frost's dramatic dialogue provides students with plenty of material to analyze from a formal perspective.

§06 More from this chapter

From the charge to the trench

14 comparisons in this chapter

See all chapters →